A couple from New Jersey, who were left with serious injuries after their Uber crashed, have been told they cannot sue the company because of the terms they accepted when using the app. Despite arguing that they had not understood they were forfeiting their right to sue, state judges ruled that the couple had clicked a "confirm" button multiple times agreeing to Uber's terms of use. The terms state that all claims must be resolved in arbitration, meaning the dispute is settled through a third party rather than in court.
Background
In a recent case in New Jersey, a couple who were injured in an Uber crash were denied the right to sue the company due to the terms of use they agreed to when using the app. The couple, identified as Michael and Danielle Simonetti, were rear-ended by an Uber driver in August 2019. They sustained serious injuries, including a broken pelvis for Michael and a herniated disc for Danielle.
The Simonettis filed a lawsuit against Uber, but the company argued that the couple had agreed to mandatory arbitration when they signed up for the service. Arbitration is a form of dispute resolution where an independent third party, known as an arbitrator, hears the case and makes a binding decision.
Court Ruling
The Superior Court of New Jersey ruled in favor of Uber, finding that the Simonettis had "knowingly and voluntarily" agreed to mandatory arbitration by clicking a "confirm" button multiple times when they created their Uber account. The court also dismissed the couple's argument that they had not understood that they were forfeiting their right to sue by agreeing to arbitration.
Implications
The ruling has raised concerns among consumer advocates, who argue that mandatory arbitration clauses in consumer contracts can prevent victims of accidents from seeking justice in court. Arbitration proceedings are often held in secret, and the decisions made by arbitrators are not subject to judicial review.
Top 5 FAQs on Mandatory Arbitration in Uber Contracts
1. What is mandatory arbitration?
Mandatory arbitration is a process where disputes are settled through a third party, known as an arbitrator, rather than in court.
2. Why do companies like Uber use mandatory arbitration clauses?
Companies argue that mandatory arbitration clauses save time and money compared to lengthy court battles. They also claim that arbitration preserves the privacy of both parties involved.
3. What are the disadvantages of mandatory arbitration?
Mandatory arbitration clauses can prevent victims from seeking justice in court, where they have the right to a jury trial and the ability to appeal decisions. Arbitration proceedings are also often held in secret, and the decisions made by arbitrators are not subject to judicial review.
4. Can I opt out of mandatory arbitration with Uber?
No. The Uber terms of use do not allow riders to opt out of mandatory arbitration.
5. What should I do if I have been injured in an Uber accident?
If you have been injured in an Uber accident, it is important to seek medical attention and contact a personal injury attorney immediately. An attorney can help you understand your rights and options and can advise you on whether to pursue arbitration or file a lawsuit.
After creating a buzz on social media, Mahindra has now announced the prices for their top models BE 6 and XEV 9e. Priced at Rs 18.9 and Rs 26.9 lakh respectively, both models can be pre-booked from February 14, 2025. Interested customers can also test drive them starting from January 14 in select cities. The BE 6 offers an impressive range and fast charging capabilities, making it a promising offering from Mahindra.
The University Grants Commission is seeking suggestions and comments from stakeholders on its proposed draft regulations for the appointment and promotion of teachers and academic staff in universities and colleges. The regulations aim to update and harmonize guidelines for academic positions across all higher education institutions in India, and will introduce new methodologies for recruitment and promotion processes. Stakeholders are urged to review the draft and contribute to the shaping of the future of academic staffing in the country.
The Indian Health Ministry is taking action as the number of HMPV cases rises to five, with two patients in Tamil Nadu and none so far in Maharashtra. The 2019 outbreak began with two infants in Bengaluru but only one remains hospitalized. The respiratory illness has flu-like symptoms such as common cold, sore throat, and fever and the ministry has directed state health officials to monitor any SARI or ILI cases. Haryana's health minister has issued an advisory for civil surgeons in regards to respiratory diseases including HMPV.
The stock market saw a sharp decline on Tuesday, with the S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite falling 0.9% and 1.6%, respectively. This was fueled by a rise in the yield of 10-year Treasurys, indicating concerns about the future of interest rates. The release of strong economic data, including better-than-expected job openings in November, also raised questions about the Fed's decision-making on rates. The tech sector was hit hard, with AI chipmaker Nvidia's stock dropping 5% after hitting an all-time high earlier in the day.
In an interesting turn of events, users of X (formerly Twitter) discovered a "X Score" feature that was touted to provide an insight into their social credit standing on the platform. However, most users were shocked when the AI assistant gave them a paltry 38 out of 100. This led to speculations of a possible algorithm tweak by X's owner Elon Musk, but later it was revealed that this was not an official feature and no changes had been made to the algorithm. So, if you're wondering why your views are going down, Musk has a simple answer for you.
Nazibur Rahman, former principal secretary to the Prime Minister's Office and National Board of Revenue chairman, has been sent to jail after his three-day remand in connection with the 2022 killing of a BNP activist. Police have implicated Rahman in the case after arresting him in October 2025. The incident began when BNP leaders and activists gathered in the capital as part of their party program. On December 7, 2022, police and AL men entered the BNP office and opened fire, injuring the activist. A case has been filed against 256 people, including Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, for their involvement in the incident.
In a major shift, Facebook, Instagram, and Threads will no longer use fact-checkers to moderate content, instead relying on community notes similar to X. The move is intended to promote free speech and reduce mistakes in content moderation. Additionally, the company will be moving its trust and safety teams responsible for content policies and moderation from California to Texas and scrapping restrictions on topics like immigration and gender identity. However, there is a trade-off as the company admits it will catch less bad content but also reduce the number of innocent posts and accounts that are accidentally removed.
According to Sky Sports journalist Manuele Baiocchini, AC Milan is considering a potential loan deal for Manchester United star Marcus Rashford. Milan sees him as a potential reserve for Rafael Leão and a backup option for Álvaro Morata and Tammy Abraham. However, Rashford's high salary of €14 million per year is a major obstacle for Italian clubs. Talks have yet to take place, but Milan is open to discussing the deal if United helps cover the salary.
Standard Glass Lining Technology Ltd. is set to raise Rs 410.05 crore through its initial public offering, which has been subscribed 16.13 times so far on Tuesday. The grey market premium for the IPO currently stands at Rs 93, suggesting a potential 66.43% premium at listing. With an issue price range of Rs 133–140 and a combination of fresh issue and offer for sale, the company has already raised Rs 123 crore from anchor investors and is set to finalise allotment on Jan. 9 with a tentative listing date of Jan. 13.
The stock market saw a sharp decline in the morning hours of trading on Monday, with the Sensex plunging close to 800 points and the Nifty tanking over 250 points. This was attributed to fresh foreign fund outflows and the cautious stance of investors ahead of the upcoming earnings season. The broader markets also traded in the red, with the Nifty Microcap 250 leading the losses and the Nifty Metal and Realty indices dominating in the red. Meanwhile, the global oil benchmark Brent crude saw a slight dip, while the US markets ended on a positive note on Friday.