Over the years, the Indian Supreme Court has faced criticism for its increasing compliance with the government's actions, leading to perceptions of it as an illiberal institution. As the Chief Justice, Chandrachud, who was once praised for his progressive and liberal values, has not lived up to the expectations of being assertive and independent. The court's handling of politically sensitive cases, such as Article 370, the Babri Masjid dispute, and bail, has tarnished Chandrachud's previous reputation and overshadowed his earlier standing as a liberal judge. Additionally, a shocking revelation from Justice Chandrachud himself has raised concerns about the court's impartiality in the controversial Ayodhya dispute.
In recent years, the Indian Supreme Court has faced criticism for its perceived compliance with the government's actions, leading to concerns about its independence and impartiality. This issue has come to the forefront under the leadership of Chief Justice DY Chandrachud, who was once praised for his progressive and liberal values.
Chief Justice Chandrachud was appointed to the Supreme Court in 2016 and became its Chief Justice in November 2022. Prior to his appointment, he served as a judge in the Bombay High Court and the Supreme Court. He was known for his liberal rulings on issues such as LGBTQ+ rights and constitutional freedoms.
Critics have accused the Supreme Court under Chief Justice Chandrachud of being overly compliant with the government, particularly in politically sensitive cases. For example, the court's handling of the following issues has drawn criticism:
In addition to allegations of compliance, the revelation by Chief Justice Chandrachud that he had met with a Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) official in the wake of the Ayodhya dispute has raised concerns about the court's impartiality. Justice Chandrachud claimed that the meeting was a coincidence, but critics have questioned whether it compromised the court's neutrality in the case.
The alleged compliance and impartiality concerns have tarnished Chief Justice Chandrachud's previous reputation as a liberal judge. Critics claim that he has not lived up to expectations of being assertive and independent.
1. Why is there criticism of the Supreme Court under Chief Justice Chandrachud? Answer: The Supreme Court is criticized for its perceived compliance with the government's actions in politically sensitive cases.
2. What are some examples of cases where the Supreme Court's handling has been questioned? Answer: Examples include the Article 370 revocation, the Babri Masjid dispute, and the granting of bail to political figures.
3. What is the concern about Chief Justice Chandrachud's meeting with a BJP official? Answer: Critics question whether the meeting compromised the court's impartiality in the Ayodhya dispute.
4. How has Chief Justice Chandrachud's reputation been affected by these allegations? Answer: His reputation as a liberal judge has been tarnished, and he is seen as not being assertive or independent enough.
5. What is the future outlook for the Supreme Court's independence? Answer: The Supreme Court's independence is being tested, and it remains to be seen whether it can maintain its neutrality and safeguard constitutional rights in the face of government pressure.
The war against the imposition of Hindi in Tamil Nadu has gained momentum and support from the people of Maharashtra, where Chief Minister M K Stalin claims it is now raging like a whirlwind. The BJP, which faced backlash for their proposal to introduce Hindi as a third language in Tamil Nadu schools, has retreated for the second time out of fear for popular uprising in Maharashtra. The estranged Thackeray cousins, Uddhav and Raj, came together after 20 years to celebrate the withdrawal of the proposal at a victory rally in Mumbai. Tamil Nadu CM M K Stalin, who is also the president of DMK, praised Uddhav Thackeray's leadership and questioned the Centre's decision to impose Hindi and Sanskrit in the name of the three-language policy, stating that it goes against India's plural culture.
In a case regarding the ban on hijab in educational institutions of Karnataka, Supreme Court Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia declared that while discipline is necessary in schools, it should not come at the cost of freedom and dignity. Despite a split verdict, Justice Dhulia rejected the comparison of a school with a military camp and emphasized that public places have certain limitations, but the case did not warrant restrictions on fundamental rights inside a classroom. He stated that the facts of the case do not justify the ban on hijab, as schools are not required to have the same level of discipline as a military camp.
Tamil Nadu's Public Works Minister EV Velu has stirred up a political controversy by slamming the Union government's financial allocation for the promotion of Sanskrit. At a public event, he ridiculed the usage of Sanskrit in Hindu wedding rituals and stressed the importance of recognizing Tamil as a vibrant, living language. Velu's statements reflect Tamil Nadu's longstanding demand for recognition and investment in its cultural heritage, with several other leaders from the ruling DMK party echoing his sentiments.
Union Minister Kishan Reddy spoke out against former Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, alleging that his decisions regarding Article 370 led to the loss of 42,000 lives in Jammu and Kashmir. He also paid tribute to Dr. Shyama Prasad Mukherjee, who sacrificed his life while fighting for the country's integrity and opposing Article 370. Reddy demanded the repeal of Article 370 and praised Prime Minister Narendra Modi for taking action to revoke it and unite the nation.
In a bold and unprecedented move, tech mogul Elon Musk has announced the creation of the "America Party" in a bid to challenge the dominance of the Republican and Democratic parties in American politics. The decision comes after Musk conducted a poll on his social media platform X, receiving overwhelming support for a third political force. This move also marks a major fallout between Musk and President Donald Trump, after Musk threatened to use his wealth to unseat lawmakers who supported a controversial tax cut and spending bill.
After a public falling out with President Trump over federal spending, billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk announced the formation of the "America Party" on his own social media platform, X. The party aims to combat what Musk sees as the country's entrenched "one-party system" and oppose lawmakers who support Trump's massive domestic spending plan. This move follows a poll on X where Musk asked if users desired "independence from the two-party system," with the majority responding yes. The feud between Trump and Musk escalated when the president pushed for his "One Big Beautiful Bill," which Musk vehemently criticized and coined as "debt slavery."
In a historic moment, Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde and Shiv Sena leader Raj Thackeray publicly shared a stage after 20 years at a victory rally in Mumbai. This reunion was prompted by the withdrawal of two government resolutions proposing the introduction of Hindi as a third language in state schools. The rally marked an important turning point in the relationship between the once-estranged Thackeray cousins.
At least five Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) workers were detained for vandalising entrepreneur Sushil Kedia's Worli office, allegedly in response to his remarks about MNS leader Raj Thackeray amid the ongoing Marathi language row. Kedia apologised for his comments and praised Thackeray's advocacy of Hindutva, calling for a more positive approach to promoting the Marathi language. Union Minister Chirag Paswan condemned the reported assault of a Thane shopkeeper over language issues, highlighting the need for unity and respect among Indians. Meanwhile, former Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis vowed to take action against such acts of "hooliganism" in Mumbai.
The main and X accounts of renowned news agency Reuters have been blocked in India on social media platform X, as users discovered and reported on Saturday. The reason for this block is yet to be officially announced, but it appears to be a result of a legal demand or local laws. Despite the main handle being inaccessible, affiliated handles of Reuters remain accessible. It's unclear whether the block is temporary or permanent and if it's linked to a specific report or legal order against the platform. Stay informed with our latest blogs.
Amidst the ongoing controversy over the assault of a shopkeeper by MNS workers, Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde caused a stir with his concluding speech at an event in Pune, where he raised the slogans "Jai Gujarat" and "Jai Maharashtra". While the opposition accused Shinde of being "greedy for power", CM Devendra Fadnavis defended him, stating that it was a customary practice to hail the state where an event is being held. The incident adds fuel to the ongoing debate on Marathi language and pride, ahead of the civic elections in Maharashtra.