In a landmark judgement, the Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of sub-categorization within Scheduled Castes for the purpose of granting quotas. CJI DY Chandrachud emphasized that the principle of equality guarantees factual and not formal equality, allowing for valid classification if there is an "intelligible differentia" and a "rational relation" to the law's objective. The verdict examines whether Article 14 (right to equality) is violated by sub-classification.
Equality: A Principle Anew
Background
The concept of equality has been a cornerstone of the Indian Constitution since its inception. Article 14 of the Constitution guarantees the right to equality for all citizens, prohibiting discrimination based on race, caste, religion, sex, place of birth, or any other ground. However, the interpretation of equality has been a subject of ongoing debate.
Landmark Supreme Court Judgment
In a recent landmark judgment, the Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of sub-categorization within Scheduled Castes (SCs) for the purpose of granting quotas. This decision has reignited the discussion on the nature and scope of equality in India.
Principle of Equality
Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud, who authored the judgment, emphasized that the principle of equality guarantees factual, not formal equality. This means that the law can distinguish between groups if there is an "intelligible differentia" (a relevant and reasonable distinction) and a "rational relation" to the law's objective.
In the instant case, the court held that the sub-categorization of SCs for the purpose of quotas is valid because it seeks to address specific disadvantages faced by certain sub-groups within the SC community. The court also noted that the sub-categorization is based on objective criteria such as geographical location, occupation, and economic status.
Critics' Arguments
Critics of the judgment argue that it violates the fundamental principle of equality by creating further divisions within a marginalized community. They contend that quotas should be granted based on overall economic and social disadvantage, rather than caste or sub-caste.
FAQs
1. What is the basis for the sub-categorization of SCs?
The sub-categorization is based on objective criteria such as geographical location, occupation, and economic status.
2. How does the judgment justify sub-categorization?
The court held that sub-categorization is valid if there is an "intelligible differentia" and a "rational relation" to the law's objective. In this case, the objective is to address specific disadvantages faced by certain sub-groups within the SC community.
3. Does the judgment erode the principle of equality?
The judgment upholds the principle of factual equality, which allows for valid classification based on relevant distinctions.
4. How will the judgment impact quotas for SCs?
The judgment will ensure that quotas for SCs are distributed more equitably among different sub-groups within the community.
5. What are the implications for other marginalized groups?
The judgment may have implications for the sub-categorization of other marginalized groups, such as Other Backward Classes (OBCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs).
In a rally in Bihar, Prime Minister Modi criticized RJD for "seizing land" and not delivering on job promises, sparking a heated response from Tejashwi Yadav. Congress and RJD workers also staged protests, citing PM Modi's failure to revive sugar mills as an example of his unfulfilled promises. Disputes over SPS regulations for India's exports to the EU have also been a topic of negotiation between India and the EU.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi, during a rally in Durgapur, launched a scathing attack on the Trinamool Congress and the Mamata Banerjee government. He criticized the mistreatment of women in West Bengal and promised to fix the state's problems by forming a new government. He also announced the inauguration of projects worth Rs 5400 crore and highlighted the importance of Durgapur in the nation's development. With a goal of transforming India by 2047, PM Modi called for development, employment, and good governance.
In a major move towards development in Bihar, Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated major infrastructure projects worth over Rs 7,000 crore. These projects, spanning across various sectors, aim to improve connectivity and overall growth in the state. Highlights include the launch of four new Amrit Bharat trains and the inauguration of multiple rail projects, including automatic signalling on the Samastipur-Bachhwara rail line.
Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta presented a shocking case to the Karnataka High Court, revealing the dangers of anonymity and lack of editorial accountability on social media platforms. While arguing against a petition challenging the Central government's "Sahyog" portal, Mehta showed a verified fake Twitter account claiming to be the "Supreme Court of Karnataka." The account could easily spread false information and millions of people would believe it to be coming from the actual Supreme Court. This highlights the urgent need for solutions to tackle such new problems posed by the internet.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi delivered a fiery speech at a rally in Durgapur, West Bengal, calling out the ruling TMC for fostering infiltration and promoting violence in the state. Modi declared that the BJP is the only party that truly values and safeguards the pride of Bengal. He also took a veiled dig at Mamata Banerjee, accusing her of playing divisive vote-bank politics and hindering Bengal's growth. With the upcoming state elections, Modi's bold statements aim to win over the hearts of Bengal's citizens and solidify BJP's foothold in the state.
In a fiery speech at a rally in Motihari, PM Narendra Modi accused the RJD of seizing land from the poor on the false promise of jobs. He claimed that the opposition alliance, which includes the Congress, has neglected the state and its people. The PM also promised to invest Rs 1 lakh crore in providing jobs and employment opportunities across the country. This comes ahead of the upcoming assembly elections in Bihar, with Modi rallying support for the NDA government and vowing to build a new Bihar.
As the West Bengal Assembly elections draw closer, the political battleground is heating up with the fight for Bengali identity and pride taking center stage. Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee is positioning herself as the defender of Bengali culture and language against the anti-Bengali stance of the BJP. With both sides gearing up for an aggressive campaign, the battle for Bengal is sure to intensify with Bengali asmita as the central issue.
In a shocking political development, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) arrested Chaitanya Baghel, son of former Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel, on his birthday, in connection with an alleged money laundering case. The arrest took place following fresh raids conducted under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act. Congress leaders have accused the Central government of political vendetta and raised questions about the timing of the arrest, which coincided with the final day of the Monsoon Session of the Chhattisgarh Assembly. Party workers gathered outside the ED's office to protest the arrest, with the Leader of Opposition Charan Das Mahant leading a walkout from the Assembly, stating that they will not be intimidated by central agencies.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi speaks at a public rally in Bihar's Motihari, highlighting the NDA government's efforts towards the all-round development of the state. He announced the inauguration and foundation laying of development projects worth thousands of crores of rupees. PM Modi also emphasized the need for industrial development in Patna and other cities in eastern India, and highlighted the government's achievements in areas such as women's empowerment and affordable housing in the state.
The Enforcement Directorate has arrested Chaitanya Baghel, son of former chief minister Bhupesh Baghel, in connection with the alleged Rs 2,100-crore liquor scam case in Chhattisgarh. This comes after fresh raids were conducted at the Baghel residence in Bhilai and officials found new evidence linking him to the scam. The arrest, which coincided with Chaitanya's birthday, has been labelled as a political vendetta by Bhupesh Baghel and highlights the existence of a structured liquor syndicate within the state's Excise Department.