In a landmark judgement, the Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of sub-categorization within Scheduled Castes for the purpose of granting quotas. CJI DY Chandrachud emphasized that the principle of equality guarantees factual and not formal equality, allowing for valid classification if there is an "intelligible differentia" and a "rational relation" to the law's objective. The verdict examines whether Article 14 (right to equality) is violated by sub-classification.
Equality: A Principle Anew
Background
The concept of equality has been a cornerstone of the Indian Constitution since its inception. Article 14 of the Constitution guarantees the right to equality for all citizens, prohibiting discrimination based on race, caste, religion, sex, place of birth, or any other ground. However, the interpretation of equality has been a subject of ongoing debate.
Landmark Supreme Court Judgment
In a recent landmark judgment, the Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of sub-categorization within Scheduled Castes (SCs) for the purpose of granting quotas. This decision has reignited the discussion on the nature and scope of equality in India.
Principle of Equality
Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud, who authored the judgment, emphasized that the principle of equality guarantees factual, not formal equality. This means that the law can distinguish between groups if there is an "intelligible differentia" (a relevant and reasonable distinction) and a "rational relation" to the law's objective.
In the instant case, the court held that the sub-categorization of SCs for the purpose of quotas is valid because it seeks to address specific disadvantages faced by certain sub-groups within the SC community. The court also noted that the sub-categorization is based on objective criteria such as geographical location, occupation, and economic status.
Critics' Arguments
Critics of the judgment argue that it violates the fundamental principle of equality by creating further divisions within a marginalized community. They contend that quotas should be granted based on overall economic and social disadvantage, rather than caste or sub-caste.
FAQs
1. What is the basis for the sub-categorization of SCs?
The sub-categorization is based on objective criteria such as geographical location, occupation, and economic status.
2. How does the judgment justify sub-categorization?
The court held that sub-categorization is valid if there is an "intelligible differentia" and a "rational relation" to the law's objective. In this case, the objective is to address specific disadvantages faced by certain sub-groups within the SC community.
3. Does the judgment erode the principle of equality?
The judgment upholds the principle of factual equality, which allows for valid classification based on relevant distinctions.
4. How will the judgment impact quotas for SCs?
The judgment will ensure that quotas for SCs are distributed more equitably among different sub-groups within the community.
5. What are the implications for other marginalized groups?
The judgment may have implications for the sub-categorization of other marginalized groups, such as Other Backward Classes (OBCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs).
The Bihar government announced a major reshuffle in the state's police ranks, transferring 62 IPS officers, including three additional directors general. Among the changes, Avakash Kumar will now take over as the SP of CID, while Kundan Krishnan has been assigned additional charge of the Special Task Force. The SP of the Economic Offences Unit will now be Rakesh Rathi, while Lalit Mohan Sharma and Amit Ranjan have been appointed as SPs in Vaishali and Sitamarhi districts respectively.
Staunch right-wing anti-immigrant campaigners and powerful Silicon Valley leaders like Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy are locked in a fierce battle over the issue of immigration, spurred by the appointment of Indian-origin Sriram Krishnan to a senior White House role under the incoming Trump administration. While some argue that the US should prioritize hiring top talent from around the world, others believe that US-born engineers should be given opportunities first. Amidst the heated debate, differences in opinion over the country's engineering shortage and the role of culture have also emerged.
Former Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh passed away on December 17th, and today his funeral will be held at Nigambodh Ghat in Delhi. Manmohan Singh, who served as the country's Prime Minister for two terms, was respected by all political parties for his leadership skills and contributions to the nation. Heavy rain and snowfall have been recorded in Delhi and nearby states, creating challenging weather conditions for the funeral ceremony. Despite this, many political and public figures are expected to pay their respects to the former Prime Minister as he is cremated today.
The 2023 Karnataka Assembly elections in the Chintamani constituency feature Dr M C Sudhakar as the Indian National Congress (INC) candidate, with declared assets amounting to Rs 65.5 crore. As per the election affidavit, he has a post graduate degree and is 54 years old. Dr M C Sudhakar has also mentioned 0 criminal cases registered against him, making him a top contestant in the upcoming elections. Keep track of live result updates to see if he secures his position as MLA for the third time.
In a shocking display of protest, BJP leader K Annamalai lashes himself six times and vows not to wear footwear until DMK is removed from power in Tamil Nadu. He also plans to visit all the six abodes of Lord Muruga to complain about the situation in the state. Despite the AIADMK being the main opposition, Annamalai's dramatic move has helped the BJP seize the initiative on the sexual assault case at Anna University in Chennai. He has also called out the party's shortcomings and questioned the whereabouts of the Nirbhaya Fund.
Tamil Nadu BJP chief K Annamalai staged a dramatic protest in Coimbatore, flogging himself to condemn the state police and ruling DMK party for their handling of a sexual assault case. The former IPS officer accused them of deliberately disclosing the victim's identity and announced that he will not wear footwear until the government is dislodged. The incident, which occurred on Christmas eve at Anna University, has sparked widespread outrage and calls for better protection of women's safety in the state.
Former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh passed away at the age of 92 on Thursday at AIIMS Delhi. His death was confirmed by AIIMS in their bulletin, which led to an outpouring of condolences from leaders across the political spectrum. Singh, known for his role in shaping modern India with economic reforms, retired to his iconic bungalow in Lutyens' Delhi after stepping down from office in 2014.
The passing of former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh at the age of 92 due to age-related health issues has left the nation in mourning. Singh, who was admitted to AIIMS Delhi on Thursday evening, is being remembered for his economic revolution and progressive changes during his tenure. Political figures, including Priyanka Gandhi's husband Robert Vadra, have expressed their condolences for Singh's family and praised his service to the country. This is a developing story, stay tuned for updates.
The streets of Patna, Bihar have been filled with chaos and tension as aspiring candidates for the Bihar Public Service Commission (BPSC) staged protests and attempted to gherao the BPSC office. With allegations of irregularities in the BPSC exams, the aspirants are demanding the cancellation and re-examination of the exam. The situation escalated when the protesting students were met with force by the police, leading to a standoff between the two groups.
A viral post claims that Udhayanidhi Stalin mocked Hinduism and proclaimed himself as a proud Christian. However, our investigation revealed that the video was edited to misrepresent Stalin's remarks. In his full speech, Stalin also identified as a Muslim and a Hindu, promoting religious equality and unity. Reports and the original footage of the speech further prove that the viral video was misleading.