In a landmark judgement, the Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of sub-categorization within Scheduled Castes for the purpose of granting quotas. CJI DY Chandrachud emphasized that the principle of equality guarantees factual and not formal equality, allowing for valid classification if there is an "intelligible differentia" and a "rational relation" to the law's objective. The verdict examines whether Article 14 (right to equality) is violated by sub-classification.
Equality: A Principle Anew
Background
The concept of equality has been a cornerstone of the Indian Constitution since its inception. Article 14 of the Constitution guarantees the right to equality for all citizens, prohibiting discrimination based on race, caste, religion, sex, place of birth, or any other ground. However, the interpretation of equality has been a subject of ongoing debate.
Landmark Supreme Court Judgment
In a recent landmark judgment, the Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of sub-categorization within Scheduled Castes (SCs) for the purpose of granting quotas. This decision has reignited the discussion on the nature and scope of equality in India.
Principle of Equality
Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud, who authored the judgment, emphasized that the principle of equality guarantees factual, not formal equality. This means that the law can distinguish between groups if there is an "intelligible differentia" (a relevant and reasonable distinction) and a "rational relation" to the law's objective.
In the instant case, the court held that the sub-categorization of SCs for the purpose of quotas is valid because it seeks to address specific disadvantages faced by certain sub-groups within the SC community. The court also noted that the sub-categorization is based on objective criteria such as geographical location, occupation, and economic status.
Critics' Arguments
Critics of the judgment argue that it violates the fundamental principle of equality by creating further divisions within a marginalized community. They contend that quotas should be granted based on overall economic and social disadvantage, rather than caste or sub-caste.
FAQs
1. What is the basis for the sub-categorization of SCs?
The sub-categorization is based on objective criteria such as geographical location, occupation, and economic status.
2. How does the judgment justify sub-categorization?
The court held that sub-categorization is valid if there is an "intelligible differentia" and a "rational relation" to the law's objective. In this case, the objective is to address specific disadvantages faced by certain sub-groups within the SC community.
3. Does the judgment erode the principle of equality?
The judgment upholds the principle of factual equality, which allows for valid classification based on relevant distinctions.
4. How will the judgment impact quotas for SCs?
The judgment will ensure that quotas for SCs are distributed more equitably among different sub-groups within the community.
5. What are the implications for other marginalized groups?
The judgment may have implications for the sub-categorization of other marginalized groups, such as Other Backward Classes (OBCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs).
The Kasibugga Venkateswara Temple in Srikakulam district was the site of a heart-wrenching stampede, causing multiple fatalities and affecting the community deeply. Chief Minister N. Chandrababu Naidu has expressed his sorrow over the unfortunate incident, as well as directing officials to ensure that those injured receive the best medical treatment possible. As local officials and public representatives are called to oversee relief operations, swift action is required to aid those affected and manage the situation effectively.
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the Shanti Shikhar Academy for Peaceful World in Raipur, praising the Brahma Kumaris organization for bridging India's ancient wisdom with the world's search for harmony. He credited the group's selfless service and spiritual discipline for their efforts towards universal peace. He positioned the Brahma Kumaris as protectors of India's soul and highlighted India's proactive role in addressing global crises such as disaster relief and environmental threats.
In an act of solidarity and protest, millions of Muslims in India used their Friday prayers to denounce the recent killings that took place in Pahalgam. The news comes amid growing tensions between the Muslim community and the Indian government. Many are viewing this as a sign of unity and determination from the Muslim population in India.
The state of Karnataka, or Kannada Rajyotsava, marked its 69th anniversary with a grand ceremony organized by the district administration in Mangaluru. District in-charge minister Dinesh Gundu Rao paid tribute to the leaders and writers who fought for a unified Kannada state and presented awards to 80 outstanding individuals and organizations. In his address, the minister highlighted the rich cultural and historical heritage of Karnataka and called for a sense of pride among its citizens.
Telangana's 'Run for Unity' event marked the 150th birth anniversary of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, India's first Deputy Prime Minister and architect of national integration. The event, carrying the message of "Ek Bharat - Shreshth Bharat", honored Patel's legacy of unity, sacrifice, and nation-building. Telangana BJP President N Ramachander Rao paid tribute to Patel and highlighted his pivotal role in integrating princely states, including Hyderabad, into the Indian Union. He also commended Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah for upholding Patel's ideals of national integrity.
The FBI has successfully stopped a potential terrorist attack in Michigan on Halloween weekend, according to FBI Director Kash Patel. Multiple suspects have been arrested after allegedly planning a violent attack that was connected to international terrorism. The suspects, whose ages range from 16 to 20, had engaged in firearms training and mentioned "pumpkin day" as a code for Halloween. White House Senior Director for Counterterrorism Seb Gorka confirmed the thwarted attack and stated that it was intended to occur during a time when children should be enjoying themselves.
Amidst criticism over his comments on his interfaith marriage to his Hindu wife, Usha, US Vice President JD Vance reiterates the importance of mutual respect, trust, and communication in their union. While he hopes she may someday embrace his Christian faith, her decision to maintain her beliefs is respected. Despite their differences, the couple has agreed to raise their children in the Christian faith, with Usha supporting them. At a Turning Point USA event, Vance also reaffirmed the couple's balanced approach towards managing their interfaith household.
Three days after TVK leader Vijay met with the family members of the victims of the Karur tragedy, Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) team led by Superintendent of Police Praveen Kumar visited the rally site in Velusamypuram where the deadly stampede occurred. The officers conducted inquiries with locals and studied the topography of the area, as well as Vijay's travel route. The transfer of the case to the CBI and the re-registration of the FIR remains a secret and its contents have not been made public yet.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi praised the demonstrations by the indigenous dog squad as one of the most admired parts of the Rashtriya Ekta Diwas parade at the Statue of Unity. The squad included breeds like Rampur Hounds and Mudhol Hounds, with Mudhol Hound "Riya" leading the pack. PM Modi also applauded the Assam Police's Motorcycle Daredevil Show and the cultural performances at the parade, which reflected the theme of "Unity in Diversity." The event was attended by five Shaurya Chakra awardees and 16 gallantry medal winners from the CRPF and BSF.
The FBI has announced the arrest of multiple individuals in Michigan who were planning a violent attack over the Halloween weekend. Director Kash Patel praised the vigilance of law enforcement personnel and assured the public that there was no threat to the community. These arrests come after a previous arrest in May of a Michigan man who allegedly planned an attack on a US Army facility on behalf of the Islamic State group. The suspect remains in federal custody and is expected to plead guilty.