Retired Bombay High Court judge Justice RC Chavan has criticised outgoing Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud for prioritising public perception in his judgments. Speaking at a panel discussion to assess the CJI's tenure and judicial legacy, Justice Chavan stated that judges should not be swayed by extrajudicial concerns and voiced his disappointment in CJI Chandrachud for being preoccupied with how history will judge him. While Senior Advocate Raju Ramachandran commended the CJI for his high standards in judgment writing, he also expressed disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case decision.
Retired High Court Judge Criticizes Former CJI Chandrachud for Prioritizing Public Perception in Judgments
Retired Bombay High Court judge Justice RC Chavan has criticized former Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud for allegedly prioritizing public perception in his judgments.
Background
DY Chandrachud served as CJI from May 2022 to November 2023. During his tenure, he authored several notable judgments, including the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict.
Criticism
Justice Chavan expressed his disapproval of CJI Chandrachud's focus on public perception during a panel discussion assessing the former CJI's tenure. He argued that judges should not be swayed by extrajudicial concerns and should prioritize the law and principles of justice. Chavan also criticized CJI Chandrachud for being preoccupied with how history would judge him.
Senior Advocate Raju Ramachandran, while praising CJI Chandrachud's high standards in judgment writing, also voiced disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case decision.
Defense of CJI Chandrachud
Supporters of CJI Chandrachud have defended his approach, arguing that it is important for judges to be aware of the public's perception of their actions. They maintain that CJI Chandrachud remained impartial and fair in his judgments.
Top 5 FAQs and Answers
1. What are the main criticisms against CJI Chandrachud? Answer: Justice Chavan criticized CJI Chandrachud for prioritizing public perception in his judgments, while Senior Advocate Ramachandran expressed disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict.
2. What are the reasons given for CJI Chandrachud's alleged prioritization of public perception? Answer: Some allege that CJI Chandrachud was concerned with how history would judge him, which influenced his decisions.
3. What are the arguments in defense of CJI Chandrachud's approach? Answer: Supporters argue that it is important for judges to be aware of the public's perception to maintain confidence in the judiciary and that CJI Chandrachud remained impartial.
4. What was the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict? Answer: The Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict ruled in favor of the Hindu side, allowing for the construction of the Ram Temple at the disputed site in Ayodhya.
5. Who is Justice RC Chavan? Answer: Justice RC Chavan is a retired judge of the Bombay High Court known for his outspoken views and criticism of the judiciary.
The Ministry of Home Affairs has extended the "Disturbed Areas" status to the jurisdictions of six police stations in Manipur's valley region, following recent incidents of violence. This move comes after months of ethnic conflict in the state, with the MHA citing ongoing sporadic violence in certain areas. While the AFSPA grants armed forces personnel the authority to use force against individuals violating the law, it also requires Central Government approval for prosecution, raising concerns about potential misuse of power.
On the birth anniversary of India's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, political leaders across the country paid their respects and remembered his contributions to the nation. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Leader of Opposition Gandhi, and Congress President Kharge all shared heartfelt messages honoring Nehru's values and ideals, which continue to guide India towards progress and inclusivity. Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi Vadra also highlighted Nehru's unwavering commitment to fearlessness and selfless service in nation-building and urged the public to not be swayed by those who spread fear.
President-elect Donald Trump has chosen Fox News host and former army veteran Pete Hegseth as his nominee for the Defense Secretary role. Critics are raising concerns about his lack of experience and right-wing views, while supporters applaud him for his strong advocacy for military members and pardons for U.S. military service members facing war crime charges. Despite some surprise and hesitancy from Republican senators, former Rep. Jason Chaffetz believes Hegseth's nomination will easily be confirmed.
Senator John Thune of South Dakota has been elected as the new majority leader for Senate Republicans, replacing Mitch McConnell. Thune, who has promised to collaborate closely with President-elect Donald Trump, won the internal election against competitors John Cornyn and Rick Scott. As the GOP prepares to take majority control of the Senate, Thune will have the challenging task of managing a divided conference, navigating Trump's demands, and securing policy wins for the new administration.
In a momentous shift of power within the GOP, South Dakota Senator John Thune has been elected as the next Senate majority leader, replacing Mitch McConnell. Thune promised to work closely with President-elect Donald Trump, despite their past differences, and will play a crucial role in enacting Trump's policy agenda. By securing the majority support of Republican senators in two rounds of secret ballots, Thune emerged victorious over competitors John Cornyn and Rick Scott. As the first competitive election for Senate leader in three decades, Thune's victory represents a new era in the GOP and a test of his leadership abilities.
In a surprise move, US President-elect Donald Trump has chosen John Ratcliffe, former director of National Intelligence and close ally, as the director of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). Amid speculation that an Indian-origin candidate may be picked, Ratcliffe's selection is seen as a more traditional choice due to his experience in counteracting foreign interference in American politics. Trump has praised Ratcliffe for his honesty and commitment to national security, and announced him as the first person to serve in both the top intelligence roles in the country.
Donald Trump has chosen John Ratcliffe, a former representative from Texas who served as Director of National Intelligence in 2020, to lead the Central Intelligence Agency. Ratcliffe faced earlier controversy when Trump attempted to appoint him as DNI in 2019, but was deemed inexperienced by Congress. He has also advised Trump on national security during his presidential campaign and served as co-chair of a think tank focused on American security. If confirmed, Ratcliffe would be the first person to serve in both of the nation's highest intelligence positions.
Hindu-American entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy has been selected by President-elect Donald Trump to oversee federal government spending in the newly-formed “Department of Government Efficiency”. This marks a major career milestone for Ramaswamy, who has risen from being Trump's rival in the 2016 presidential race to becoming one of his influential supporters. A self-proclaimed 'apolitical' businessman, Ramaswamy recently made headlines for his criticisms of 'woke' culture and has now announced his presidential campaign for the Republican Party in 2023.
The constituency of Dumka, located in the Jharkhand Legislative Assembly, is set to hold its Assembly Elections on November 20th. With a total of 165,820 eligible voters, the main parties vying for the seat are the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM). In the previous elections, JMM's Hemant Soren came out victorious, defeating BJP's Lois Marandi. The result for Dumka will be declared on November 23rd along with the other 80 constituencies in Jharkhand. Both the BJP and JMM are yet to announce their candidates for the upcoming elections, making the political landscape in Dumka even more intriguing.
The 2024 Assembly Elections in Jamshedpur East, Jharkhand has become a closely watched battleground as Congress candidate Ajoy Kumar faces off against BJP candidate Purnima Das Sahu in a bid to retain his seat. With a significant reduction in the margin of votes in the last election, both parties have pulled out all the stops to secure victory. This election also marks the return of BJP's Raghubar Das, a constant winner from 1995 to 2014, as their candidate. The results will have a significant impact on the state's political landscape as the BJP aims to regain control from the Hemant Soren-led JMM.