Retired Bombay High Court judge Justice RC Chavan has criticised outgoing Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud for prioritising public perception in his judgments. Speaking at a panel discussion to assess the CJI's tenure and judicial legacy, Justice Chavan stated that judges should not be swayed by extrajudicial concerns and voiced his disappointment in CJI Chandrachud for being preoccupied with how history will judge him. While Senior Advocate Raju Ramachandran commended the CJI for his high standards in judgment writing, he also expressed disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case decision.
Retired High Court Judge Criticizes Former CJI Chandrachud for Prioritizing Public Perception in Judgments
Retired Bombay High Court judge Justice RC Chavan has criticized former Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud for allegedly prioritizing public perception in his judgments.
Background
DY Chandrachud served as CJI from May 2022 to November 2023. During his tenure, he authored several notable judgments, including the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict.
Criticism
Justice Chavan expressed his disapproval of CJI Chandrachud's focus on public perception during a panel discussion assessing the former CJI's tenure. He argued that judges should not be swayed by extrajudicial concerns and should prioritize the law and principles of justice. Chavan also criticized CJI Chandrachud for being preoccupied with how history would judge him.
Senior Advocate Raju Ramachandran, while praising CJI Chandrachud's high standards in judgment writing, also voiced disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case decision.
Defense of CJI Chandrachud
Supporters of CJI Chandrachud have defended his approach, arguing that it is important for judges to be aware of the public's perception of their actions. They maintain that CJI Chandrachud remained impartial and fair in his judgments.
Top 5 FAQs and Answers
1. What are the main criticisms against CJI Chandrachud? Answer: Justice Chavan criticized CJI Chandrachud for prioritizing public perception in his judgments, while Senior Advocate Ramachandran expressed disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict.
2. What are the reasons given for CJI Chandrachud's alleged prioritization of public perception? Answer: Some allege that CJI Chandrachud was concerned with how history would judge him, which influenced his decisions.
3. What are the arguments in defense of CJI Chandrachud's approach? Answer: Supporters argue that it is important for judges to be aware of the public's perception to maintain confidence in the judiciary and that CJI Chandrachud remained impartial.
4. What was the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict? Answer: The Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict ruled in favor of the Hindu side, allowing for the construction of the Ram Temple at the disputed site in Ayodhya.
5. Who is Justice RC Chavan? Answer: Justice RC Chavan is a retired judge of the Bombay High Court known for his outspoken views and criticism of the judiciary.
BR Patil, Congress MLA from Karnataka's Aland, has claimed that there was an attempt by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) to steal votes leading up to the 2023 elections in the state. This allegation, backed by evidence of over 6,000 voter deletions, has been supported by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi who has accused the BJP of systematically deleting the names of Congress voters. The BJP has denied these allegations, calling it a ploy by the Congress to discredit them and gain political mileage. However, Gandhi has hinted at more significant revelations to come.
Union Minister for Heavy Industries and Steel, H.D. Kumaraswamy, slammed the Karnataka government for the deteriorating state of Bengaluru's infrastructure, which has resulted in an IT company moving out of the city. He criticized Chief Minister Siddaramaiah and Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar for their negligence and corruption. Kumaraswamy appealed to the industries not to leave Bengaluru and promised to rebuild the city. He also called out the government for their failure in utilizing taxpayers' money for development and demanded answers for the same.
In a press conference, Congress leader and Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi unveiled evidence showing a widespread conspiracy to delete voters from electoral rolls in India. He presented examples and detailed data indicating that the alleged operations were carried out through automated systems and coordinated at a centralized level. Gandhi claimed that these tactics were used to manipulate elections in several states, and also accused the Election Commission of facilitating this voter deletion.
During a press conference, Rahul Gandhi accused Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar of aiding the suppression of votes belonging to marginalized communities like Dalits and minorities. The Election Commission denied the allegations, stating that no vote can be deleted online without proper procedures and investigation. However, the poll body did acknowledge failed attempts to delete votes in Karnataka's Aland constituency in 2023 and an FIR has been filed to investigate. The Congress leader claimed that the Election Commission is purposely obstructing investigations to hide the truth about these deletions.
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi once again stirred up controversy by accusing the BJP and Election Commission of systematic voter fraud through manipulation of electoral rolls. In response, BJP MP Anurag Thakur fired back, accusing Gandhi of spreading baseless allegations and undermining democracy. The Election Commission has dismissed all of Gandhi's claims, citing that no voter's name can be deleted through online means without proper procedure.
Congress Leader Rahul Gandhi is set to address a press conference on Thursday, where he is expected to present evidence of alleged vote theft in Indian elections. Gandhi has been vocal about the issue in previous speeches, accusing the government of using unfair means to form their power. He also claimed that the Election Commission is working in collaboration with the ruling party. The Congress promised to provide proof to back their claims and expose corruption in the Mahadevapura Assembly segment in Karnataka.
The centre has directed the removal of 138 YouTube videos and 83 Instagram posts related to Adani, citing a Delhi court order. The move comes amid ongoing disputes over the Adani Group's involvement in various projects. This action has been met with criticism, with some questioning the government's interference in online content.
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi revealed that the party has uncovered over 6,000 voter deletions in Aland constituency, Karnataka, ahead of the 2023 Assembly elections. According to their investigation, these deletions were not random or accidental but specifically targeted booths where the party was performing strongly. The deletions were carried out through fake applications and mobile numbers from outside Karnataka, raising concerns of an organized effort to manipulate the election process. Congress is calling for a thorough investigation to uphold the integrity of the democratic process.
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi has strongly criticized Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, accusing him of protecting those involved in "vote chori" (vote stealing) and undermining democracy. He cited recent instances of voter deletions in Karnataka's Aland and fraudulent additions in Maharashtra's Rajura as evidence of systematic targeting of Congress voters. Speaking at a press conference, Gandhi urged for a fair and transparent election process to uphold the principles of democracy.
Congress MP and leader of opposition in Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, held a news conference and claimed that the Chief Election Commissioner is protecting those who are destroying the Constitution and democracy in India. He also alleged that a group of people is systematically cutting the votes of minority groups who vote for the Congress party. In response, politicians from different parties have dismissed his accusations and stated that he is making these statements out of desperation and frustration.