Retired Bombay High Court judge Justice RC Chavan has criticised outgoing Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud for prioritising public perception in his judgments. Speaking at a panel discussion to assess the CJI's tenure and judicial legacy, Justice Chavan stated that judges should not be swayed by extrajudicial concerns and voiced his disappointment in CJI Chandrachud for being preoccupied with how history will judge him. While Senior Advocate Raju Ramachandran commended the CJI for his high standards in judgment writing, he also expressed disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case decision.
Retired High Court Judge Criticizes Former CJI Chandrachud for Prioritizing Public Perception in Judgments
Retired Bombay High Court judge Justice RC Chavan has criticized former Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud for allegedly prioritizing public perception in his judgments.
Background
DY Chandrachud served as CJI from May 2022 to November 2023. During his tenure, he authored several notable judgments, including the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict.
Criticism
Justice Chavan expressed his disapproval of CJI Chandrachud's focus on public perception during a panel discussion assessing the former CJI's tenure. He argued that judges should not be swayed by extrajudicial concerns and should prioritize the law and principles of justice. Chavan also criticized CJI Chandrachud for being preoccupied with how history would judge him.
Senior Advocate Raju Ramachandran, while praising CJI Chandrachud's high standards in judgment writing, also voiced disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case decision.
Defense of CJI Chandrachud
Supporters of CJI Chandrachud have defended his approach, arguing that it is important for judges to be aware of the public's perception of their actions. They maintain that CJI Chandrachud remained impartial and fair in his judgments.
Top 5 FAQs and Answers
1. What are the main criticisms against CJI Chandrachud? Answer: Justice Chavan criticized CJI Chandrachud for prioritizing public perception in his judgments, while Senior Advocate Ramachandran expressed disappointment in the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict.
2. What are the reasons given for CJI Chandrachud's alleged prioritization of public perception? Answer: Some allege that CJI Chandrachud was concerned with how history would judge him, which influenced his decisions.
3. What are the arguments in defense of CJI Chandrachud's approach? Answer: Supporters argue that it is important for judges to be aware of the public's perception to maintain confidence in the judiciary and that CJI Chandrachud remained impartial.
4. What was the Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict? Answer: The Ayodhya Ram Temple case verdict ruled in favor of the Hindu side, allowing for the construction of the Ram Temple at the disputed site in Ayodhya.
5. Who is Justice RC Chavan? Answer: Justice RC Chavan is a retired judge of the Bombay High Court known for his outspoken views and criticism of the judiciary.
The recent decision by the Andhra Pradesh High Court to restore the membership of MLC Indukuri Raghu Raju has cast doubt over the upcoming MLC election in Vizianagaram. The disqualification of Raju, who belongs to the YSR Congress Party, was due to allegations of anti-party activities. While the ruling party has named a new candidate for the election, the opposition TDP is yet to announce its candidate. With just weeks to go before the election, the district election machinery is in a state of confusion as to whether there will be an election at all.
As the Maharashtra Assembly Elections of 2024 near, campaigning is in full swing with parties vying for majority seats. However, police and a poll flying squad seized 2,700 ration kits containing campaign materials from an independent candidate in Nagpur, leading to a case being registered. This seizure shows the heightened competitiveness of the upcoming elections.
Imran Khan, Chairman of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, condemns the current Pakistani government for undermining democracy and suppressing dissent. He criticizes the government for using unconstitutional means to protect their power grab, including censoring the media and seizing control of the Supreme Court. Khan calls on his party and the Pakistani people to fight for their rights and freedoms, declaring his willingness to face consequences for resistance.
In a press conference on Monday, the head of Japan's Democratic Party for the People, Yuichiro Tamaki, admitted to having an extramarital affair as reported in a magazine. The scandal has caused a stir in the country, especially since the party had recently gained more seats in parliament. Tamaki plans to listen to his peers' opinions before deciding whether to step down as head of the party, but he has stated that he has no intention of resigning as a lawmaker.
Former President Donald Trump voiced his support for Bitcoin at the 2024 conference in Nashville, Tennessee. He labeled the cryptocurrency as the future of currency, causing a surge in Bitcoin's value. This comes after Trump's recent praise for blockchain technology and his own involvement in the industry.
In an intense exchange of fire between police and suspected militants in Manipur, 10 people were killed, including a CRPF jawan, marking the highest number of fatalities in a single day this year. The incident occurred in the Jiribam district, close to the hills of the Hmar community, one of the tribes involved in the ongoing conflict in the state. The violence comes days after the killing of a woman from the Hmar community, with a group representing armed Hmars claiming that those killed in the exchange of fire were "village volunteers" retaliating against her death. The situation remains tense in the district, with indefinite prohibitory orders issued by the district administration.
Usha Chilukuri Vance has been thrust into the spotlight as her husband, JD Vance, joins the political arena as Vice President. Born in San Diego to Indian immigrants, she comes from a family of accomplished academics. Her impressive academic background and support for her husband make her a force to be reckoned with. However, Usha has largely remained out of the political limelight, focusing on her career and family.
On the afternoon of November 11, 2024, armed militants launched an attack on a CRPF post and nearby police station in Jiribam District, India. The security forces responded with strong retaliation, resulting in one injured CRPF constable named Sanjeev Kumar. The incident highlights the ongoing threat of militant attacks in the region and the bravery of security forces in defending against them.
As Maharashtra gears up for the upcoming Assembly elections, national leaders take a backseat as state leaders become the focal point of the political landscape. With marquee leaders like Eknath Shinde of Shiv Sena and Devendra Fadnavis of BJP fighting for their own dominance, the role of regional leaders becomes crucial. Amidst this, Deputy CM Ajit Pawar faces the heat while Uddhav Thackeray struggles to establish himself as the real Shiv Sena leader. The Congress also adopts a localised strategy, leaving the NCP camp to rely on the master strategist, Sharad Pawar. With multiple factors at play, the Maharashtra elections have become a highly contested battle with each of the 288 constituencies being influenced by distinct issues.
Several shops belonging to the Meitei community were set ablaze by suspected Kuki militants in Manipur's Jiribam district, raising questions about the effectiveness of security forces. The attacks took place within close proximity of a police station, highlighting the urgent need for increased security measures to protect the local population. This incident is part of the ongoing violence in Manipur, which has caused displacement and destruction.