Rahul Gandhi, Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha, spoke against the Modi government during his first speech of the session. However, parts of his speech were expunged from the records. This drew parallel to similar incidents in the past, where his and other Opposition leaders' remarks were removed. This has sparked a debate on the freedom of speech in Parliament and the role of the Speaker in controlling proceedings.
Kharge, Gandhi's Speeches Expunged: A Question of Freedom of Speech in Parliament
During their recent speeches in Lok Sabha, Congress leader Mallikarjun Kharge and Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi faced the expungement of portions of their remarks from parliamentary records. This incident sparked a debate about the freedom of speech in Parliament and the role of the Speaker in controlling proceedings.
Background
The expungement of parliamentary speeches is a long-standing practice aimed at maintaining decorum and preventing the dissemination of offensive or misleading information. However, in recent years, there have been concerns about the increasing use of this power to suppress critical voices and limit the scope of debate.
Kharge's Speech
On February 10th, 2023, Mallikarjun Kharge delivered a speech in Lok Sabha alleging that the Modi government had weakened the judicial system and was interfering in its functioning. The Speaker, Om Birla, expunged several portions of his speech, including references to the appointment of judges and the role of the Chief Justice of India.
Gandhi's Speech
On February 9th, 2023, Rahul Gandhi made a speech criticizing the Modi government's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic and the Adani-Hindenburg controversy. The Speaker expunged numerous portions of his speech, including allegations of corruption and a reference to the Prime Minister as "Mr. Modi."
Debate on Freedom of Speech
The expungement of Kharge and Gandhi's speeches has sparked a heated debate on the limits of free speech in Parliament. Opposition leaders and media commentators have accused the Speaker of suppressing dissent and undermining the legislature's accountability function. Supporters of the expungement, however, argue that it is necessary to prevent personal attacks and protect the reputation of individuals and institutions.
FAQs
1. What is the purpose of expunging parliamentary speeches? Expungement removes portions of a speech from official records to maintain decorum and prevent the dissemination of offensive or misleading information.
2. Who has the authority to expunge speeches? The Speaker of the House has the authority to expunge speeches.
3. What criteria are used to decide whether a speech should be expunged? The criteria include offensive language, personal attacks, unsubstantiated allegations, and statements that breach parliamentary norms.
4. Have there been similar incidents of expungement in the past? Yes, there have been several instances in the past where speeches by Opposition leaders have been expunged from parliamentary records.
5. What are the concerns raised by the recent expungements? Critics argue that the increasing use of expungement is suppressing critical voices and limiting the scope of debate in Parliament.
The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) faced a major setback in the recently concluded Lok Sabha elections, winning only 33 out of 80 seats in the crucial state of Uttar Pradesh. This dealt a blow to the party's hopes of securing a majority in the national parliament, and pushed the Samajwadi Party to the second position with 37 seats. The BJP's underwhelming performance has sparked discussions within the party regarding its campaign strategies and leadership.
Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) leader Hemant Soren was sworn in as Jharkhand Chief Minister for the third time on July 4, 2024, amidst high tension. He had resigned as CM in January after being arrested by the Enforcement Directorate in a money laundering case. Soren's father and JMM supremo Shibu Soren, mother Rupi Soren, and other senior leaders of the JMM-led alliance were present at the ceremony along with former CM Chamapi Soren, who resigned on Wednesday.
Hemant Soren, Executive President of Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, was sworn in as the Chief Minister of Jharkhand for the third time on Thursday at a ceremony attended by top political leaders. This comes after Soren was granted bail in a money laundering case, just seven days after his arrest. This political development marks an end to the five-month-long tenure of outgoing Chief Minister Champai Soren.
According to a recent report, Lewis Hamilton's aggressive driving style has been causing issues with Mercedes' tires, preventing him from performing at his best. With the 2024 Pirelli tires being more sensitive, Hamilton's braking and accelerating tactics have been putting too much strain on them. This has led to struggles for the reigning world champion at the start of the 2024 season, with his last race win in 2021.
In the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, the Bharatiya Janata Party has emerged victorious in all five seats in Uttarakhand, thanks to Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami's efficient election strategy and management. This clean sweep victory was made possible by the hard work of party workers and the strong support of the people, who have shown their trust in the BJP. Prime Minister Narendra Modi's affection for Uttarakhand and Devbhoomi has been a key factor in this historic win, with over two lakh crores worth of schemes being approved for the state.
The UK's ongoing general election could bring an end to 14 years of Conservative rule as predictions show the Labour Party on track for a historic victory. Amidst infighting and scandals within the Conservative Party and a cost-of-living crisis affecting the nation, British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak cast his vote on Thursday with fears of losing his own seat. With a record number of ethnic minority MPs expected to be voted into Parliament, the election's outcome could reflect the diversity of the British electorate.
Senior BJP leader and Rajasthan Agriculture Minister Kirodi Lal Meena has resigned from the state cabinet, following through on his promise to step down if the party lost any of the seven Lok Sabha seats in the recent polls. The results, announced on June 4, saw the party lose in Meena's hometown of Dausa. The 72-year-old leader had made the pledge during the election campaign.
Amidst the coverage of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Lok Sabha speech in the Motion of Thanks, leading news channels were accused of showing indifference to the Hathras stampede where over 100 people lost their lives. Insensitive reporting and government's lack of empathy towards the incident is being criticized. It is found that the incident took place before 3 pm, yet it took TV news channels nearly three hours to make it the headline. This has sparked a debate on media priorities and government accountability.
AAP MP Raghav Chadha has called for the harshest action against those involved in organizing the Hathras Satsang event, stating that the edited video circulating showed the blatant disregard for COVID-19 protocols. The Enforcement Directorate has also revealed that a key person involved in the AAP's alleged excise policy scam was a cash handler for the party in the upcoming Goa elections. Meanwhile, security outside Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's Delhi residence has been heightened after intelligence inputs of possible disturbance from right-wing groups.
Jharkhand's Chief Minister Champai Soren has resigned, paving the way for his son Hemant Soren to return to the position of Chief Minister. Hemant Soren, who had previously served as CM for two terms, was unanimously elected leader of the ruling alliance's legislators at a meeting where he was released on bail after being jailed for five months on a money laundering charge. The move has been criticized by opposition spokesperson Vinay Singh, who accused of dynastic politics, but alliance leaders state that the move is for a unified command ahead of the upcoming State elections in October.