Murty's comments about the origins of the Rakhi tradition have prompted discussions and debates online. While some have praised her for shedding light on lesser-known historical events, others have criticized her for spreading a false narrative. The story of Rani Karnavati and Humayun's supposed involvement in the tradition has been called into question due to the lack of historical evidence.
Humayun and the Origins of Rakhi: Debunking Myths and Unraveling Historical Truths
Background:
The festival of Raksha Bandhan, popularly known as Rakhi, is a sacred Hindu tradition in which sisters tie a consecrated thread called a "rakhi" on their brothers' wrists, symbolizing the bond of protection and love between siblings. While the origins of this tradition are shrouded in myth and legend, one popular story attributes its genesis to the Mughal emperor Humayun and the Rajput queen Rani Karnavati.
Murty's Comments and Subsequent Controversy:
In recent years, noted Indian author Amish Tripathi sparked a heated debate by claiming that the Rakhi tradition originated not from the Humayun-Karnavati story but from a pre-Islamic practice in which women tied a protective talisman known as a "raksha" around the wrists of male warriors. This claim spurred discussions and debates online, prompting scrutiny of the historical evidence surrounding the Humayun-Karnavati narrative.
Historical Evidence and Challenges to the Humayun-Karnavati Story:
Historical records provide limited evidence to support the involvement of Humayun and Rani Karnavati in the establishment of the Rakhi tradition. Contemporary accounts of the period make no mention of any such event, and the story first appears in written form in the 19th century, raising questions about its authenticity.
Furthermore, the absence of any archaeological findings or inscriptions from the era suggests that the Humayun-Karnavati story may be a later fabrication or embellishment. Critics argue that the tale was likely created to glorify the Rajputs and foster a sense of Hindu-Muslim unity during the British Raj.
Top 5 FAQs and Answers:
1. Q: Is the Humayun-Karnavati Rakhi story historically accurate?
A: No, there is no substantial historical evidence to support the claim that Humayun and Rani Karnavati were involved in the origins of the Rakhi tradition.
2. Q: What is the earliest known evidence of the Rakhi tradition?
A: The earliest evidence of Rakhi-like practices dates back to ancient India, where women tied amulets or protective threads around the wrists of warriors.
3. Q: What is the significance of the raksha or talisman?
A: The raksha was believed to possess protective powers and was often tied around the wrists or necks of individuals to ward off danger or illness.
4. Q: Why has Murty's claim sparked controversy?
A: Murty's claim challenges the widely accepted Humayun-Karnavati narrative, which has been popularized in literature, art, and folklore. Additionally, his comments raise questions about the manipulation and fabrication of historical events.
5. Q: What are the potential implications of Murty's claim?
A: While Murty's claim has provoked discussion and debate, it does not diminish the significance of the Raksha Bandhan tradition. The festival remains a cherished celebration of siblinghood and protection, regardless of its specific origins.
Conclusion:
The origins of the Rakhi tradition remain shrouded in mystery, and the Humayun-Karnavati story may be just one of many tales that have shaped the narrative. Murty's comments have sparked a necessary examination of the historical evidence, but they should not be taken as a definitive refutation of the tradition's deep-rooted significance in Indian culture.
Nara Bhuvaneswari, Managing Trustee of NTR Trust, has been recognized for her lifelong dedication to voluntary social service by receiving the 'Distinguished Fellowship Award' from the Institute of Directors. She joins a list of illustrious awardees such as Dr A P J Abdul Kalam and Rajashree Birla, and has earned a unique name for herself through her tireless efforts in transforming the lives of thousands of underprivileged individuals through various initiatives of the Trust. Her selfless service and international recognition serve as a beacon of hope, inspiring others to follow her footsteps in making a positive impact on society.
A joyful occasion turned tragic in Mirzapur as a 17-year-old boy drowned and another remains missing during Chhath Puja celebrations. The incident occurred when five villagers entered River Ganga to take a ritual bath and began struggling in the water. While three were rescued by a local boatman, two boys were swept away. Mirzapur police are now continuing the search for the missing teenager and local divers have recovered the body of one of the boys. Similar unfortunate incidents have been reported in Jharkhand, with eleven people, mostly children, drowning in separate incidents during the past two days.
As predicted by the Regional Meteorological Department, parts of Tamil Nadu and Puducherry are experiencing light to moderate rainfall, along with thunderstorms and lightning. Due to the heavy rain alert, schools in Chennai will remain closed along with other districts such as Cuddalore, Villupuram, Ranipet, Puducherry, and Karaikal. The iconic Marina Beach in Chennai is also facing intense sea turbulence with rough waves and strong winds. Meanwhile, people in Thoothukudi are facing waterlogging due to continuous heavy rainfall.
The Delhi Traffic Police has issued a crucial advisory in preparation for the upcoming Chhath Puja celebrations in the city, which will take place on October 27 and 28, 2025. The advisory warns of potential heavy traffic and diversions near major water bodies and encourages commuters to use public transportation to avoid delays and congestion. The public is also reminded to report any suspicious activities and cooperate with the authorities for a safe and orderly celebration.
The Delhi Traffic Police has announced special traffic arrangements for the upcoming Chhath Puja celebrations in the city. Heavy footfall is expected at major ghats and ponds in different parts of Delhi, leading to diversions and restrictions on various roads. Commuters are advised to use public transport and avoid areas with expected gatherings.
The holy relics will be taken in a grand Guru Charan Yatra through various cities in India before finding a permanent home at Takht Sri Patna Sahib, the birthplace of the tenth Sikh Guru. This marks a significant moment for the community and a way to deepen their connection with the teachings of Sri Guru Gobind Singh and Mata Sahib Kaur.
As festivities for Chhath Puja 2025 begin, schools in the national capital Delhi, as well as in Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, and Jharkhand, have announced closures on October 27, with additional holiday time for those in Bihar. In West Bengal, schools will be closed on October 31 for another significant festival, Jagadhatri Puja. With official announcements expected soon, students can look forward to enjoying the celebrations with their families.
The Hyderabad District Collector, Hari Chandana IAS, has launched India's first QR code-based feedback system at the Collectorate, marking a major step towards transparent and people-centric governance. This innovative system allows citizens to easily provide feedback, suggestions, and grievances in real-time, without the need for formal paperwork or technical skills. Along with promoting administrative efficiency and accountability, this initiative also promotes citizen participation and empowerment by enabling them to directly influence government operations at the local level.
Piyush Pandey, one of the most influential minds in Indian advertising, passed away on Thursday at the age of 70. Renowned for his iconic moustache and love for everyday stories, Pandey reshaped the industry by incorporating Hindi and Indian expressions, bringing humor, heart, and authenticity to mainstream brand communication. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman expressed their grief over the loss of Pandey, who was credited with revolutionizing Indian advertising and communication. His work will continue to inspire generations to come.
A private bus carrying 41 passengers caught fire after colliding with a motorcycle on National Highway 44 in Kurnool district, Andhra Pradesh. Preliminary police investigations suggest that the motorcycle's fuel tank ruptured and leaked fuel, causing the fire. The bus was reported to have multiple challans for traffic violations, and investigations are ongoing to determine the exact cause of the accident.