Murty's comments about the origins of the Rakhi tradition have prompted discussions and debates online. While some have praised her for shedding light on lesser-known historical events, others have criticized her for spreading a false narrative. The story of Rani Karnavati and Humayun's supposed involvement in the tradition has been called into question due to the lack of historical evidence.
Humayun and the Origins of Rakhi: Debunking Myths and Unraveling Historical Truths
Background:
The festival of Raksha Bandhan, popularly known as Rakhi, is a sacred Hindu tradition in which sisters tie a consecrated thread called a "rakhi" on their brothers' wrists, symbolizing the bond of protection and love between siblings. While the origins of this tradition are shrouded in myth and legend, one popular story attributes its genesis to the Mughal emperor Humayun and the Rajput queen Rani Karnavati.
Murty's Comments and Subsequent Controversy:
In recent years, noted Indian author Amish Tripathi sparked a heated debate by claiming that the Rakhi tradition originated not from the Humayun-Karnavati story but from a pre-Islamic practice in which women tied a protective talisman known as a "raksha" around the wrists of male warriors. This claim spurred discussions and debates online, prompting scrutiny of the historical evidence surrounding the Humayun-Karnavati narrative.
Historical Evidence and Challenges to the Humayun-Karnavati Story:
Historical records provide limited evidence to support the involvement of Humayun and Rani Karnavati in the establishment of the Rakhi tradition. Contemporary accounts of the period make no mention of any such event, and the story first appears in written form in the 19th century, raising questions about its authenticity.
Furthermore, the absence of any archaeological findings or inscriptions from the era suggests that the Humayun-Karnavati story may be a later fabrication or embellishment. Critics argue that the tale was likely created to glorify the Rajputs and foster a sense of Hindu-Muslim unity during the British Raj.
Top 5 FAQs and Answers:
1. Q: Is the Humayun-Karnavati Rakhi story historically accurate?
A: No, there is no substantial historical evidence to support the claim that Humayun and Rani Karnavati were involved in the origins of the Rakhi tradition.
2. Q: What is the earliest known evidence of the Rakhi tradition?
A: The earliest evidence of Rakhi-like practices dates back to ancient India, where women tied amulets or protective threads around the wrists of warriors.
3. Q: What is the significance of the raksha or talisman?
A: The raksha was believed to possess protective powers and was often tied around the wrists or necks of individuals to ward off danger or illness.
4. Q: Why has Murty's claim sparked controversy?
A: Murty's claim challenges the widely accepted Humayun-Karnavati narrative, which has been popularized in literature, art, and folklore. Additionally, his comments raise questions about the manipulation and fabrication of historical events.
5. Q: What are the potential implications of Murty's claim?
A: While Murty's claim has provoked discussion and debate, it does not diminish the significance of the Raksha Bandhan tradition. The festival remains a cherished celebration of siblinghood and protection, regardless of its specific origins.
Conclusion:
The origins of the Rakhi tradition remain shrouded in mystery, and the Humayun-Karnavati story may be just one of many tales that have shaped the narrative. Murty's comments have sparked a necessary examination of the historical evidence, but they should not be taken as a definitive refutation of the tradition's deep-rooted significance in Indian culture.
The iconic Burj Khalifa, the tallest building in the world, paid a heartwarming tribute to Indian PM Modi on his 75th birthday by lighting up with a special greeting and his image. This gesture of friendship and partnership between India and UAE was also reciprocated by Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the President of UAE, who wished Modi a day full of happiness, health, and continued success for India. Amidst all the isms in the world, IBNS strives to serve objective news without any bias, leaving the judgment to the readers.
The Supreme Court has recognized Vantara, a top Indian animal conservation centre, for its exceptional practices that go beyond national regulations and surpass international standards. Amidst a growing global concern for animal welfare, Vantara's commitment to science-driven and compassionate care sets a new benchmark in the field. Independent certifications and audits have certified Vantara's holistic framework, making it a model institution for rescue and rehabilitation of animals. The vision of Anant Ambani, the facility's founder, has elevated Vantara as a leader in ethical, transparent, and meaningful conservation of animals.
The Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) has started the "Swachhata Hi Seva 2025" campaign as part of the Swachh Bharat Mission, with a focus on promoting community involvement in keeping the city clean. The campaign was inaugurated by NMC Commissioner Dr. Abhijit Chaudhary, who flagged off a 72-hour cleanliness drive in all ten zones of Nagpur. With special squads of sanitation workers deployed and various programs planned, the initiative aims to make Nagpur a cleaner, greener, and healthier city.
After the abrogation of Article 370, Lal Chowk in Srinagar has become a hub of cultural and social activities. Recently, the Akhil Bhartiya Gau Sewa Foundation launched a 180-day padyatra from Lal Chowk to Kanyakumari, to create awareness about cow protection. The padyatra was flagged off with a ceremonial worship of a hybrid cow, symbolizing the region's transformation towards peace and development. This event showcases the changing atmosphere of Lal Chowk post-Article 370 and highlights the importance of cow protection in India.
After heavy rains triggered a landslide near the Vaishno Devi shrine in Jammu, at least 30 people were killed and several injured. Rescue operations are currently underway to search for any survivors or trapped individuals. In addition to this tragedy, Indian exporters are facing hefty 50% tariffs on goods being exported to America starting today. Stay informed by following the Indian Express on Instagram.
The Travancore Devaswom Board has started repair work on the gold-plated panels adorning the guardian sculptures at Sabarimala Sree Kovil, but not without facing criticism and opposition. The work is being done in Chennai due to the unavailability of electroplating facilities at the temple premises, but this decision has been met with objections from the former priest of the temple. Despite the Board's efforts to justify their actions, the controversy continues to surround the repair of these sacred panels, which have been the subject of much devotion and controversy in the past.
Engineer's Day is celebrated in India on September 15th to honor the legacy of M. Visvesvaraya, a pioneering engineer. It's a day to recognize and appreciate the hard work and technical expertise that engineers bring to society. To make Engineer’s Day 2025 special, here are some inspiring wishes, thoughtful quotes, and fun messages to send to the engineers in your life. Happy Engineer's Day to all the innovators, problem-solvers, and visionaries!
The ninth day of Pitru Paksha, known as Matru Navami, holds immense significance for Hindus. On this day, special rituals of shradh are performed to honor and seek blessings from departed mothers, sisters, and daughters. The shradh of Matru Navami is considered to bring peace and salvation to the souls of ancestors, while also fostering the bond of motherhood in the lives of those who perform it. Along with charity and other rituals, it is a day dedicated to honoring the maternal side and upholding ancestral respect.
This year, on September 15, India celebrates Engineers' Day to honour the legacy of M. Visvesvaraya, a distinguished civil engineer, scholar and statesman. From designing dams to modernising water management systems, Visvesvaraya's innovative contributions have left a lasting impact on India's infrastructure. Recognised for his stellar achievements and dedicated service, he was honoured with the title of 'Sir' by King George V of Britain and the Bharat Ratna by the Government of India. As we celebrate the legacy of the 'Father of Modern Mysore', we also mark the UNESCO-recognised World Engineering Day for Sustainable Development on March 4 each year, emphasising the role of engineers in advancing the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals.
On September 14 every year, India celebrates Hindi Diwas to honor the day Hindi was adopted as the official language in 1949. The day aims to raise awareness about the importance of the language, which has also influenced the English language with many words of Hindi origin. This article takes a look at 10 fascinating facts about Hindi, including its global reach and influence.