Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw stated that the NDA government is bound to follow the Constitution drafted by BR Ambedkar, which does not include any provision for creamy layer in SC/ST reservation. The Union Cabinet, chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, discussed the recent Supreme Court ruling on sub-categorisation of SC/ST reservation. The top court ruled that states can sub-classify SC/STs and even identify the creamy layer to exclude them from affirmative action, but the Union Minister ensured that the government is committed to Ambedkar's constitutional provisions.
Supreme Court Ruling on Creamy Layer Exclusion from SC/ST Reservation: A Deeper Dive
Background
The term "creamy layer" refers to individuals within marginalized communities who have achieved a certain level of socioeconomic success. Historically, the creamy layer concept has been applied to SC/ST reservation policies to exclude those who are no longer considered economically backward. However, the recent Supreme Court ruling has created a controversy.
Supreme Court Ruling
In May 2022, the Supreme Court ruled that states can sub-categorize SC/ST communities and identify a creamy layer to exclude them from reservation benefits. This decision was based on the argument that creamy layer individuals have already benefited from reservation and should not continue to access it.
Government's Response
The Union Cabinet, chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has stated that it is bound by the Constitution drafted by B.R. Ambedkar, which does not include any provision for a creamy layer in SC/ST reservation. Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw emphasized that the government is committed to Ambedkar's constitutional provisions.
FAQs
1. Why has the creamy layer concept been applied to SC/ST reservation?
To ensure that reservation benefits reach the most economically disadvantaged individuals within marginalized communities.
2. What is the rationale behind the Supreme Court's ruling?
To prevent individuals who have already achieved socioeconomic success from continuing to benefit from reservation at the expense of those who are still in need.
3. What is the government's position on the ruling?
The government is committed to Ambedkar's constitutional provisions, which do not include a provision for creamy layer exclusion in SC/ST reservation.
4. What are the potential implications of implementing a creamy layer in SC/ST reservation?
It could reduce the number of individuals who benefit from reservation, thereby undermining the objective of empowering marginalized communities.
5. What is the historical precedent for the creamy layer concept in reservation?
The concept was first introduced in OBC (Other Backward Classes) reservation in 1993 to address concerns about the perpetuation of privilege within marginalized communities.
The bypoll for the Meerapur Vidhan Sabha constituency in Uttar Pradesh has attracted attention with a total of 11 candidates vying to be elected as the MLA. The constituency, which is part of the Bijnor Lok Sabha seat, has been necessitated due to the resignation of Chandan Chauhan. Stay updated with live result updates to find out who will be the new Member of Legislative Assembly for Meerapur.
A heated debate has arisen between the Samajwadi Party and the BJP over the issue of voter identity verification for Muslim women wearing burqas, hijabs, niqabs, and ghunghats in the upcoming UP by-election. The Samajwadi Party has approached the Election Commission demanding that Muslim women should not have to remove their burqas for checks, while the BJP argues that every voter must be identified. The Election Commission has confirmed that only the polling officer is authorised to verify voter ID cards, and police or security personnel are not permitted to check ID cards or request a woman to remove her burqa. As polling continues, the outcome of this controversy remains to be seen.
Amidst growing controversy and criticism, the ruling BJP in Uttar Pradesh seems to have a dilemma over its slogan, "Batoge to Katoge" coined by CM Yogi Adityanath. Within the party, Deputy CM Keshav Prasad Maurya has expressed ignorance about the slogan's context, causing opposition parties to question the party's unity. The BJP's attempts to present a consistent narrative seem to have failed as even party leaders like Ajit Pawar have spoken against the slogan. With differing slogans from top leaders, the opposition accuses the BJP of contradictions.
The results for the Maharashtra and Jharkhand Assembly polls are in, with the Shiv Sena-NCP alliance and the JMM facing a stiff challenge from the BJP. Despite facing internal divisions, the Maha Yuti alliance in Maharashtra looks set to secure a victory. Meanwhile, in Jharkhand, the JMM, bolstered by its I.N.D.I.A. allies, is expected to retain power. Stay updated with live updates and coverage on Deccan Herald and make sure to follow their Whatsapp, X, Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram channels for more news.
In the recently concluded Maharashtra Assembly elections, the Congress faced a major defeat in direct contests with the BJP, winning only 10 out of 75 seats. This is a significant decline from their performance in the Lok Sabha polls earlier this year. The BJP's average vote share per seat contested rose by 6 percentage points, while the Congress saw a decline of 14 percentage points. In some key constituencies, the Congress finished in fourth place, highlighting the immediate need for the party to reassess its strategies and connect with the voting public.
In a surprising turn of events, the Bharatiya Janata Party-led Mahayuti alliance has emerged victorious in the Maharashtra Assembly elections, securing a record-breaking 234 out of 288 seats. With the BJP coming out as the single largest party, winning 132 seats on its own, all eyes are now on who will be the Chief Minister of the state. The ruling alliance's stunning win has left Shiv Sena and Sharad Pawar's NCP far behind, with only 57 and 10 seats respectively. As celebrations break out in the winning camps, the people of Maharashtra eagerly await the next CM's announcement.
The INDI Alliance, led by Jharkhand Mukti Morcha's (JMM) Hemant Soren, secured a clear victory with 56 seats in the Jharkhand Assembly Elections 2024. The alliance's biggest partner, JMM, bagged 34 seats while Congress and RJD received 16 and 4 seats respectively. On the other hand, BJP-led NDA fell short with only 24 out of 81 assembly seats, out of which BJP alone won 21. The Jharkhand assembly elections were held in two phases and a total of 1,211 candidates were in the electoral race.
Despite initial confidence in the Maha Vikas Aghadi alliance's victory in the Maharashtra Assembly elections, Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut retracts statement and claims the results are not acceptable. This comes as the alliance struggles to maintain their lead against the MahaYuti alliance. In response, BJP Minister Chandrakant Patil extends an invitation to Shiv Sena chief Uddhav Thackeray to rejoin the MahaYuti, stating their comfortable position in forming the next government. The decision for the next chief minister will be made by the top leadership of the BJP and MahaYuti.
The ruling Mahayuti alliance is set for their third straight term in Maharashtra as they lead with 234 seats. PM Modi has praised their victory, while CM Eknath Shinde and Dy CM Ajit Pawar express their gratitude to the people. Meanwhile, the INDIA bloc is leading with 56 seats in Jharkhand, with JMM's Hemant and Kalpana Soren emerging as winners. In Maharashtra, BJP has won 125 seats, Shiv Sena has won 55, and NCP has won 40, while in Jharkhand, the BJP has won 24. Despite some internal disputes, the alliance has come out victorious with a strong lead in both states.
Aaditya and Amit Thackeray, political cousins in Maharashtra, have had varied outcomes in the latest assembly elections. While Aaditya managed to win a second term with thanks to his uncle's influence, Amit lost out on his maiden polls and can attribute some of the loss to his own uncle's decision. This highlights the complicated family politics at play in India and the impact it has on election results. The strongholds of Worli and Mahim saw three-way contests, with the MNS's entry proving to be a game-changer. The close margins highlight that a direct face-off between Aaditya and rival Milind Deora or between Mahesh Sawant and Eknath Shinde Sena can produce different results.