The National Stock Exchange of India has been hailed as a success story, but recent events have revealed a darker side. The exchange's alleged misuse of technology and regulatory capture have led to the infamous algo scam, causing huge losses for investors. Find out more about this scandal in "Scam92", a must-read for every investor. Also, don't miss out on "Pathbreakers 1 & 2" which offer deep insights into the lives of top achievers. And for unbiased financial information, consider subscribing to Moneylife for complete access to their archives and articles.
Zerodha and the Algo Scam: A Deeper Dive
Background
Zerodha is one of India's largest stockbrokers, boasting over 10 million active clients. However, recent revelations have cast a shadow over the company's reputation.
In 2019, the National Stock Exchange of India (NSE) was accused of allowing certain high-frequency trading (HFT) firms to gain preferential access to its trading platform, allowing them to front-run other traders and profit unfairly. This practice, known as the "algo scam," led to substantial losses for investors.
Zerodha's Involvement
Zerodha was one of the brokers implicated in the algo scam. The exchange was accused of granting preferential access to HFT firms through a software update that allowed them to bypass the exchange's normal order flow and place their trades ahead of others.
As a result of the allegations, Zerodha's founder and CEO, Nithin Kamath, was banned from the securities market for one year by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) in 2020. Zerodha was also fined Rs. 10 crore ($1.3 million).
Top 5 FAQs
1. What is the algo scam?
The algo scam refers to the illegal practice of HFT firms using a software update provided by the NSE to gain preferential access to the trading platform, allowing them to front-run other traders and profit unfairly.
2. Who was involved in the scam?
The NSE and several HFT firms, including Tower Research Capital, OPG Securities, and Sampark Infocomm, were involved in the scam. Zerodha was one of the brokers that facilitated the HFT firms' access.
3. How did the scam impact investors?
The scam led to significant losses for investors who were unaware of the preferential access granted to HFT firms. The manipulation of the market by these firms resulted in unfair trading and decreased returns for ordinary investors.
4. What was Zerodha's role in the scam?
Zerodha provided the trading platform and allowed the HFT firms to use the software update that gave them preferential access to the NSE. The company was aware of the potential for manipulation and did not take adequate steps to prevent it.
5. What are the consequences for Zerodha and other parties involved?
SEBI imposed a one-year ban on Nithin Kamath and fined Zerodha Rs. 10 crore. The NSE was fined Rs. 50 crore and six of its top officials were banned for up to two years. The HFT firms involved were also penalised.
Conclusion
The algo scam has been a major blow to the reputation of India's financial markets. It has exposed the vulnerabilities of the trading system and the potential for abuse by market participants. The ongoing investigations into the scam and the penalties imposed on Zerodha and other parties involved serve as a reminder of the importance of ethical conduct and regulatory oversight in the securities industry.
Indian equities continued their upward trend for the second day, with Nifty and Sensex both registering gains of over 1.5%. Bank Nifty also saw an increase of nearly 2%, led by gains in HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank, SBI and Axis Bank. This surge can be attributed to the positive sentiment post the state election results, which have been deemed as highly positive for the market. Analysts predict that the rally may continue for a few more days, driven by short covering and bullish momentum. Meanwhile, Asian markets also traded in the green as the US Treasury secretary selection caused a downward movement in the dollar and bond yields.
HDFC Bank's stock soared to an all-time high as it received a delivery-based buying of Rs 31,135 crore as part of MSCI rebalancing. The private lender recorded a delivery volume of 17.4 crore shares, with a delivery percentage of over 81%, driving its market capitalisation to reach an impressive Rs 13.57 lakh crore. The November round of MSCI indices rejig is expected to bring in foreign passive flows of $2.5 billion, boosting the bank's weightage in the Global Standard Index. This news has attracted the attention of investors, with BSE Ltd. also recording a high delivery turnover worth Rs 2,928 crore.
Hindustan Unilever Limited (HUL) has recently separated its ice cream business, with a valuation exercise already completed. However, the move has faced complications as a panel formed by HUL to evaluate the prospects of this business has discovered that softy ice cream mix is subject to an 18% GST. In addition, a video showing tampering of Amul ice cream has resurfaced, causing concerns for GCMMF. These developments, along with HUL's earnings and FII outflows, have contributed to a fall in the markets for the fourth day in a row. Despite this, there is a silver lining as the Sensex has rebounded, with FMCG seeing growth and Adani Energy receiving a SEBI notice for its shareholding categorization.
In a significant move, India will see its weight in the MSCI Emerging Markets Index rise from 19.3% to 19.8% in 2024, leading to an estimated $2.5 billion in passive foreign inflows. This increase is largely due to notable upgrades for several Indian companies, including Kalyan Jewellers India Ltd., Voltas Ltd., and BSE Ltd. With no Indian stocks removed, India's total representation in the index expands to 156, and an additional 13 Indian stocks have been added to the MSCI Small-Cap Index. This surge in representation not only boosts India's weight in the index but also signals potential for further growth and upgrades in the future, solidifying its position in global markets.
The much-awaited IPO of NTPC Green Energy is set to be finalised today, with allotment messages being sent to investors. The grey market premium has seen a slight increase over the weekend, with the stock currently trading at a premium of 2.78%. The listing date is scheduled for November 27 and interested investors can check the official IPO allotment status on various platforms such as BSE, NSE, and Kfin Technologies. Additionally, the allotment status can also be checked easily by following certain steps.
Following a recent post by a user named "DogeDesigner," which claimed that X had become the #1 news app on Apple's AppStore in India, billionaire Elon Musk confirmed the news. Musk acquired X, formerly known as Twitter, in October of 2022 for $44 billion. According to Statista.com, India ranks third in the world for the number of Twitter users, with over 25 million users. After the announcement, Musk's followers praised the platform, with users from Australia, Germany, Brazil, and India congratulating X on its achievement. This comes after a mass exodus of users from X to alternative platforms, like Bluesky, after the 2024 United States presidential election.
Delhi-based water and wastewater management provider, Enviro Infra Engineers Ltd., launched its initial public offering on Friday, which was fully subscribed at 2.08 times. As of Monday, the IPO has been subscribed 8.34 times, with a grey market premium of Rs 52 and an estimated listing price of Rs 200 per share. The company aims to raise Rs 650.43 crore through the public issue, with a price band of Rs 140-148 per share and a minimum bid requirement of 101 shares. Enviro Infra had previously raised Rs 195 crore from anchor investors and its IPO will close on November 26, with a fresh issue of Rs 572.46 crore.
In a groundbreaking partnership, Octaviant Financial and Starr Insurance have teamed up with Marsh to offer drug warranty services for pharmaceutical companies. Through their subsidiary, Actuaria Insurance Services LLC, Octaviant will provide comprehensive drug warranties, backed by Starr as the lead underwriter. These warranties are issued directly to end payers, providing them with financial recovery if a patient does not achieve the intended benefits from a high-cost therapy. As pharmaceutical companies continue to develop advanced therapies with high price tags, this partnership offers a solution to address concerns from payers and promote confidence in these innovative treatments.
After changing its name and main object of business, Spright Agro Limited has now ventured into the world of agricultural trading and commodities. With a history of successful textile production and recent operations in the steel industry, the company is expanding its already diverse portfolio. This new move is expected to greatly impact the market, making Spright Agro a force to be reckoned with. Along with their dedicated customer care and support, this move proves that the company is committed to continuously evolving and staying ahead of the game.
The Indian Premier League (IPL) 2025 mega auction kicked off in Saudi Arabia with a bang, as cricketers like Shreyas Iyer, Rishabh Pant, and Arshdeep Singh were sold at record-breaking prices. Rishabh Pant was picked up by Lucknow SuperGiants for a whopping price of ₹27 crore, making him the most expensive player in IPL history. Other notable sales include England's Jos Buttler to Gujarat Titans for ₹15.50 crore and Australia's Mitchell Starc to Delhi Capitals for ₹11.75 crore. With a total of 577 players up for auction and different budgets for each team, it will be an interesting event to follow.