Former New Zealand cricketer Simon Doull criticized India's decision to send Mohammed Siraj as a nightwatchman after Yashasvi Jaiswal's dismissal in the third Test between India and New Zealand in Mumbai. Despite India's intentions being clear, the ploy backfired as Siraj was dismissed for a golden duck. Doull believes R Ashwin would have been a better option given his batting prowess against spin. However, he also understands the psychological reasoning behind the move.
Mohammed Siraj as Nightwatchman: A Disastrous Decision by India
During the third Test match between India and New Zealand in Mumbai, India's decision to send young pacer Mohammed Siraj as a nightwatchman after the dismissal of opener Yashasvi Jaiswal drew criticism from former New Zealand cricketer Simon Doull.
Background
A nightwatchman is a batter who is sent in to bat late in the day, usually when the regular batters are tired or there is a risk of losing a wicket against spin. Their primary role is to protect the wickets of the main batters and see out the remaining overs of the day's play.
Doull's Criticism
Doull questioned India's decision to send Siraj, a bowler with a limited batting ability, as a nightwatchman. He argued that R Ashwin, a more experienced and skilled batter against spin, would have been a better choice.
"Siraj is a bowler, he's not a batter," Doull said. "Ashwin is a genuine all-rounder, he can bat, bowl, and field. I would have sent Ashwin in that situation."
India's Reasoning
Despite Doull's criticism, India may have had their reasons for sending Siraj instead of Ashwin. Siraj is a left-handed batter, which could have given India an advantage against New Zealand's right-arm spinner Ajaz Patel. Additionally, he has a reputation for being an aggressive batter, which could have given India a quick start to their innings.
The Result
However, the ploy backfired spectacularly as Siraj was dismissed for a golden duck, edging a delivery from Patel to the wicketkeeper.
Doull's Psychological Explanation
Doull acknowledged that India's decision may have been based on psychological factors as well. Sending a bowler as a nightwatchman can intimidate the opposition and send a message that the team is not afraid of losing wickets.
"Maybe they were trying to send a message to New Zealand," Doull said. "But it didn't work out that way."
FAQs
Why is a nightwatchman used? To protect the wickets of the main batters and see out the remaining overs of the day's play.
Who is a typical nightwatchman? A low-order batter who is not expected to score many runs but can defend against the opposing bowlers.
What factors influence the selection of a nightwatchman? Batting ability against the type of bowlers facing, handedness, and psychological impact.
Is it always the best decision to send a nightwatchman? No, it depends on the circumstances of the match and the availability of suitable batters.
What happened when India sent Siraj as a nightwatchman? Siraj was dismissed for a golden duck, exposing the fragility of India's top order and leading to criticism from some experts.
As the F1 2021 season comes to a close, Lewis Hamilton has come to the defense of his title rival Max Verstappen, amid criticism of the Red Bull driver's aggressive driving style. Despite the duo's intense battle for the championship, Hamilton insisted that Verstappen's approach to racing has not changed, and that the incidents in Mexico were just part of the competition. With the Brazilian Grand Prix set to be another tense showdown between the two, fans can expect to see some exciting and potentially controversial moments on the track.
Amidst the highly competitive and intense atmosphere of the Olympic Games, a crucial mistake by head coach Cecile Landi resulted in gymnast Jordan Chiles losing her chance at a medal. With seconds to spare in the final moments of the competition, Landi missed the submission deadline for an inquiry, leading to a score change that ultimately cost the team a bronze medal. As the gymnastics community grapples with the aftermath of this incident, it serves as a poignant reminder of the challenges and pressure faced by elite athletes in their pursuit for Olympic glory.
In a highly anticipated Riyadh Derby between Al-Nassr and Al-Hilal, the latter will be without star player Neymar, who is still recovering from an ACL injury. With a star-studded squad and an unbeaten record so far this season, Al-Hilal remains at the top of the league standings and is expected to put on another dominant performance against their bitter rivals. Meanwhile, Al-Nassr will be looking to close the six-point gap and secure a win in front of their home crowd. With the winter transfer window approaching, fans are eagerly waiting to see when Neymar will make his league debut for Al-Hilal.
After 11 long years, East Bengal has finally made it to the knockouts of an Asian tournament. The team's 3-2 win over Nejmeh SC in the final AFC Challenge League group stage match secured their spot as table-toppers and earned them direct entry to the quarterfinals. This is a major achievement for the Indian football club and a proud moment for its fans.
Indian spinner Ravindra Jadeja took five wickets, while Washington Sundar grabbed four as New Zealand struggled to score against the home team on day one of the third Test match. The Indian side dominated the Kiwis as their batsmen, including captain Virat Kohli, failed to deliver in the crucial match. With just four runs to his name, Kohli was dismissed after a brain-fade moment caused a run-out. The Kiwis were eventually bowled out for 235, with Jadeja's five-wicket haul and Rohit Sharma's reckless shot leading the way for India's bowling attack.
With Amorim taking over as Manchester United manager, questions arise as to which players on the squad will thrive under his coaching style and which may struggle. Football analyst Raaes Mahmood shares his insights on the potential impact of Amorim's arrival, including how midfielder Manuel Ugarte may benefit, but why forward Marcus Rashford could face challenges. Keep up with the latest updates on Manchester United's club page and watch The Football News Show on iPlayer.
In a scorching hot third test match between India and New Zealand, the tourists struggled to hold their ground as Indian spinner Ravindra Jadeja's five-wicket haul helped restrict them to 235 runs. Despite strong performances from Daryl Mitchell and Will Young, India's Shubman Gill and Rishabh Pant managed to hold on to their wickets, ending the day at 86-4. However, in a surprising turn of events, India's captain Virat Kohli ran himself out for just four runs, giving the visitors a slight advantage going into day two.
With the IPL mega auction approaching, the Gujarat Titans have announced their plan to retain key players from their team. Captain Shubman Gill, star spinner Rashid Khan, and left-handed batter Sai Sudharsan are all set to return to the team, along with uncapped players Rahul Tewatia and Shahrukh Khan. The franchise is looking to build a strong team for the upcoming season, with the retention of these players expected to bring success on the field.
Despite a half-century from opener Eoin Morgan, England faced a heavy defeat in the first one-day international against West Indies in Antigua. The match was affected by rain, with West Indies winning by eight wickets on the DLS method. This loss puts England in a difficult position as they look to bounce back in the series.