Dancing with the Stars: Carrie Ann Inaba's Controversial Judging

Carrie Ann Inaba, a longtime judge on the hit dance competition show, has come under fire in recent weeks for her scoring practices. Viewers have accused Inaba of inconsistency and bias, particularly when it comes to comparing her scores to those of her fellow judges, Bruno Tonioli and Derek Hough.

Background of the Controversy

The most recent controversy erupted during the show's 31st season, when Inaba gave contestant Chandler Kinney a score of 9 out of 10 for her Viennese Waltz. Fans were outraged, as Kinney's performance was widely considered to be one of the strongest of the night. In contrast, Inaba had awarded a 10 to contestant Heidi D'Amelio for a routine that many felt was less technically proficient.

The disparity in scoring raised questions about Inaba's objectivity and whether she was applying the same standards to all contestants. Viewers took to social media to express their frustration and disappointment, accusing Inaba of being overly critical and inconsistent in her judgments.

Inaba's Response

Inaba has defended her scoring, stating that she "scores based on what I see in the moment" and that she is "trying to be as fair as possible." She has also acknowledged that she has "a very high standard" and that she "wants to see excellence from the contestants."

Top 5 FAQs

• Why has Carrie Ann Inaba been criticized for her judging? Inaba has been accused of inconsistency and bias in her scoring compared to her fellow judges.
• What specific incident sparked the recent controversy? Inaba's score of 9 for Chandler Kinney's Viennese Waltz, while awarding a 10 to Heidi D'Amelio for a less proficient routine.
• What is Inaba's response to the criticism? Inaba has defended her scoring, saying that she judges based on what she sees and holds the contestants to a high standard.
• Will Inaba's judging style change in the future? It is unclear whether Inaba will adjust her approach in response to the criticism.
• How does Inaba's scoring compare to that of her fellow judges? While Inaba tends to give slightly lower scores than Tonioli and Hough, there is no evidence to suggest that she is consistently biased against specific contestants.

Conclusion

Carrie Ann Inaba's scoring on Dancing with the Stars has become a source of controversy among fans. While viewers are entitled to their opinions, it is important to note that judging in a subjective art form can be challenging. Ultimately, it is up to the judges to decide how they evaluate the performances and award scores.