A division bench of the Calcutta High Court has placed a public interest litigation (PIL) before the Chief Justice for proper adjudication, after hearing arguments regarding a previous determination made by Justice Amrita Sinha in cases related to police inaction or excesses. The PIL, filed by advocate Sanjay Das, argues that Justice Sinha's determination may be influenced by her husband's ongoing investigation by the West Bengal CID. This development adds to the existing controversy surrounding Justice Sinha's rulings, including criticism from the TMC government. With the court set to reopen on June 10 and the roster of justices to be changed, it remains to be seen whether Justice Sinha will continue handling these cases or if they will be reassigned.
Public Interest Litigation in India: Calcutta High Court Controversy
Background
Public interest litigation (PIL) is a legal action filed by a citizen or organization on behalf of the public or a group of persons who are unable to approach the court themselves. PILs have played a significant role in India in addressing issues of public concern and holding authorities accountable.
Calcutta High Court Controversy
A recent PIL filed in the Calcutta High Court has raised concerns about the impartiality of Justice Amrita Sinha in cases related to police inaction or excesses. The PIL alleges that Justice Sinha's husband is being investigated by the West Bengal CID, which may create a conflict of interest.
Arguments in the PIL
The PIL argues that:
Reaction from the Court
A division bench of the Calcutta High Court has placed the PIL before the Chief Justice for proper adjudication. The court has indicated that it will consider the allegations and decide whether Justice Sinha will continue to handle cases related to police inaction or excesses.
Controversy Surrounding Justice Sinha
Justice Sinha has been criticized in the past for her rulings in other cases. The TMC government has accused her of being biased against it. In March 2022, she was criticized for granting bail to a TMC MLA accused of murder.
Top 5 FAQs
1. What is PIL? PIL is a legal action filed by a citizen or organization on behalf of the public.
2. Why is Justice Sinha's impartiality being questioned? Her husband is being investigated by the West Bengal CID, which may create a conflict of interest.
3. What is the allegation against Justice Sinha? She is accused of being biased against the police and favoring petitioners in cases related to police action.
4. What is the status of the PIL? The PIL has been placed before the Chief Justice for proper adjudication.
5. What might happen to Justice Sinha's cases? The court may decide to reassign the cases to another judge.
Conclusion
The controversy surrounding Justice Amrita Sinha and public interest litigation in the Calcutta High Court highlights the importance of judicial impartiality and transparency. The outcome of the PIL will determine whether the court will uphold the principles of justice and fairness.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited the Gulf Spic Labour Camp during his two-day visit to Kuwait and interacted with Indian workers, recognizing their contributions to the country's development. He also shared his vision for a "Viksit Bharat 2047" that is supported by the aspirations of these workers. Modi also emphasized on the hard work of Indian farmers and laborers saying that it motivates him to work even harder. The Prime Minister also mentioned the cost-effective data rates in India that facilitate easy communication for people around the world.
A controversial Indian guru known as Rampal and 14 of his followers have been given a life sentence for the murder of four women and a young child at his ashram in 2014. The victims died from suffocation after being locked in a room during a stand off between the guru's supporters and police. This sentencing comes after years of legal battles and controversies surrounding the guru and his followers.
The 55th GST Council meeting in Jaisalmer resulted in a flood of demands for disaster-specific levy by several states, following a request from Andhra Pradesh for a 1% GST levy to fund their flood recovery efforts. A Group of Ministers has been formed to examine the legal and structural issues surrounding this proposal, which was discussed in detail during the council meeting. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman stated that other states such as Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal, and Telangana have also expressed interest in being a part of the committee. The issue of a similar flood-cess levy by Kerala in 2019 was also brought up, with other states showing support for Andhra Pradesh's demand.
After highly anticipated negotiations, the Mahayuti alliance announced its cabinet portfolios for Maharashtra's ministers on Saturday evening. Highlights include CM Devendra Fadnavis retaining the Home Ministry and Eknath Shinde of the Shiv Sena receiving the Urban Development portfolio. This comes after the alliance dropped several leaders from its cabinet expansion. The winter session of the Maharashtra legislative assembly concluded today with six days of intense discussions and debates. Additional key meetings will take place today regarding the portfolio distribution for the new cabinet, with several key players vying for key positions.
The Foreign Secretary has confirmed that the UK has had "diplomatic contact" with Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, the group responsible for overthrowing Syrian President Bashar-al Assad. This comes after a period of uncertainty about whether the UK should engage with HTS due to its designation as a terrorist organization. Despite its proscription, the UK maintains diplomatic contact with HTS as a necessary measure.
The National Students’ Union of India Punjab President, Isherpreet Singh Sidhu, strongly condemns the arrest of Aden Karanveer Singh by SHO Narinder for peacefully protesting for Senate Elections at the Panjab University Bachao Morcha. Sidhu highlights how such actions not only violate the democratic right to dissent but also lead to the loss of Punjab's bright minds and the creation of figures like Lawrence Bishnoi. He calls for immediate action against SHO Narinder and urges higher authorities to intervene and ensure justice for the students. Sidhu reaffirms NSUI Punjab's support for the students and their demand to be heard, respected, and empowered.
The Assembly was abuzz with discussions on the tragic Sandhya Theater stampede, with AIMIM floor leader Akbaruddin calling for a thorough investigation into the incident. He also criticized Allu Arjun for not visiting the hospital to meet the victims. CM Revanth Reddy assured that a comprehensive investigation would be conducted and necessary action would be taken in response to the incident.
Isherpreet Singh Sidhu, the National Students' Union of India Punjab President, strongly denounces the arrest of Karanveer Singh for peacefully protesting at the Panjab University Bachao Morcha and the alleged manhandling by SHO Narinder. Sidhu considers this a violation of democratic principles and a tactic used to suppress the voices of Punjab's youth. He demands immediate and strict action against the police officer and urges higher authorities to intervene and ensure justice for the students. The NSUI Punjab stands in solidarity with the students, emphasizing the need to respect their voices and empower them.
In a fiery speech, Telangana Chief Minister Revanth Reddy addressed the criticism from opposition leaders regarding the Rythu Bharosa scheme. He assured citizens that the government is committed to fulfilling all promises made and provided updates on the scheme's implementation. Reddy also highlighted the inclusivity of the process and denounced the previous government for misusing funds meant for farmers.
Congress leader Laxmi Hebbalkar, who is known for her feisty demeanor, has been embroiled in a recent controversy where she has accused BJP MLC C T Ravi of using derogatory terms against her. She has taken a stand for women's rights and filed a complaint of sexual harassment against Ravi, leading to his arrest. Hebbalkar, who is considered a close associate of Deputy Chief Minister D K Shivakumar, has managed to secure the support of the Congress leadership in her fight against injustices. However, her political career has not been without drama and controversies, including a falling out with the Jarkiholi brothers.