Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi Vadra expressed concern after Congress MP Deepender Hooda was reprimanded by Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla for chanting ‘Jai Samvidhan’ during Shashi Tharoor's oath-taking ceremony. The Speaker had earlier interrupted the opposition's chant, stating that Tharoor was already taking oath on the Constitution. This incident has raised questions about freedom of expression in Parliament.
Title: Freedom of Expression in Parliament: The 'Jai Samvidhan' Controversy
Background:
On August 26, 2022, during the oath-taking ceremony of newly elected Congress MP Shashi Tharoor, a group of opposition MPs, including Deepender Hooda, raised the slogan "Jai Samvidhan" (Hail the Constitution). However, Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla interrupted their chant, stating that Tharoor was already taking oath on the Constitution.
This incident sparked outrage among the opposition, who accused the Speaker of suppressing freedom of expression in Parliament. Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi Vadra expressed concern, questioning the rationale behind the restriction.
Detailed Analysis:
The 'Jai Samvidhan' controversy highlights the delicate balance between maintaining order and respecting freedom of expression in Parliament. While it is essential to ensure the smooth functioning of parliamentary proceedings, it is equally important to allow MPs to voice their sentiments and hold the government accountable.
Some argue that the Speaker's decision was justified to prevent disruptions and uphold the sanctity of the oath-taking ceremony. Others maintain that the opposition's chanting was a legitimate form of protest and should not have been stifled.
The controversy also raises questions about the past precedents and interpretations of parliamentary rules regarding freedom of expression. In 2016, then-Speaker Sumitra Mahajan had allowed MPs to chant "Bharat Mata Ki Jai" (Victory to Mother India) during a similar ceremony.
Top 5 FAQs and Answers:
1. Why did the Speaker interrupt the chanting of "Jai Samvidhan"?
The Speaker stated that Tharoor was already taking oath on the Constitution, which inherently implied allegiance to its principles.
2. Was the Speaker's decision consistent with past precedents?
In the past, Speakers have allowed MPs to chant slogans during oath-taking ceremonies, including "Bharat Mata Ki Jai" and "Vande Mataram."
3. Does the Speaker have the authority to restrict freedom of expression in Parliament?
The Speaker is responsible for maintaining order and ensuring the proper functioning of parliamentary proceedings. However, this authority must be exercised in a fair and impartial manner.
4. What is the significance of the "Jai Samvidhan" slogan?
The slogan "Jai Samvidhan" is a symbol of respect and reverence for the Indian Constitution, which is regarded as the supreme authority of the nation.
5. What are the potential implications of this controversy?
The 'Jai Samvidhan' controversy could set a precedent for the future restriction of freedom of expression in Parliament, or it could lead to a reconsideration of parliamentary rules regarding such matters.
Conclusion:
The 'Jai Samvidhan' controversy has sparked a debate about the role of freedom of expression in Parliament. While it is important to maintain order and decorum, it is equally essential to ensure that MPs can freely voice their views, hold the government accountable, and express their allegiance to the Constitution. The future handling of such incidents will shape the delicate balance between these competing interests.
The prestigious Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS) faced backlash from students, political leaders, and activists after their decision to dismiss 100 teaching and non-teaching staff due to lack of funds. The Progressive Students' Forum (PSF) and other student bodies condemned the mass termination and urged the administration to revoke the order. Meanwhile, opposition parties like CPI (M) and RJD criticized the BJP-led government for its "misplaced priorities" in higher education. The institute has now withdrawn the order after the Tata Education Trust assured to provide necessary resources.
After a three-month hiatus due to the Model Code of Conduct for the election, Prime Minister Narendra Modi brought back his popular radio show, Mann Ki Baat. In its 111th episode, he highlighted the unique and diverse contributions of communities in India, from Kerala's Karthumbi umbrellas to Andhra Pradesh's Araku coffee to Kashmir's snow peas. He also congratulated the 65 crore voters and everyone involved in the successful execution of the world's largest election. Here are 10 things he spoke about in the episode.
An investigation by the CBI has uncovered a major corruption racket involving 14 officials and 18 agents at two Passport Seva Kendra (PSK) centres in Mumbai. The officials were found to have colluded with the agents to issue passports based on inadequate or incomplete documents, or by manipulating personal data of applicants. The CBI has also seized mobile phones and evidence of suspicious transactions worth lakhs during their search operation at 33 locations.
BJP MLA T Raja Singh demands the cancellation of comedian Daniel Fernandes' show in Hyderabad after a video featuring insensitive jokes on the Jain community goes viral. In a stern warning, Singh threatens to have the show cancelled and threatens physical violence against Fernandes if he dares to perform. This incident has sparked a debate on the limits of comedy and the role of politicians in censoring free speech.
General Upendra Dwivedi, a decorated and experienced officer, has taken charge as the new Chief of the Army Staff (COAS) of the Indian Army. He has a distinguished career spanning over three decades, with a balanced exposure in different regions and operational environments. General Dwivedi's appointment comes at a crucial time when India is facing multiple security challenges along its northern, western, and eastern borders. As COAS, he will be responsible for the strategic planning and oversight of operations in these areas, as well as guiding the modernization and self-reliance efforts of the Indian Army.
In a press conference in Pune, Nationalist Congress Party chief Sharad Pawar announced that his party, along with the Congress and the Shiv Sena, will form a coalition to contest the upcoming Maharashtra Assembly polls in October. Mr. Pawar emphasized the moral responsibility of major Opposition parties to protect the interests of smaller allies, and called for a change in the State.
The Assam Police have confirmed the arrest of nine individuals, including the prime accused, in connection with a marksheet scam at Gauhati University. The crackdown, which has spanned multiple locations including Guwahati, Barpeta, and Dhubri, came to light after Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma shared startling revelations during a press briefing in Barpeta. Sarma noted that the Barpeta police and CID are handling the case with confidentiality, but raised concerns that similar scams could be occurring in other universities. It is important to note that the scam was uncovered after discrepancies were detected in the marks of an undergraduate student at Ganeshlal Choudhary College in Barpeta Road.
Union Ministers, BJP and JD(S) MPs from Karnataka have submitted a joint memorandum to Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, criticizing the state government's handling of finances. They claim that the state's fiscal situation has deteriorated due to mismanagement, leading to high inflation and increased borrowings. However, Siddaramaiah dismisses the allegations, stating that the state's financial condition is under control.
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has taken over the alleged paper leak case of the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test Undergraduate (NEET UG). The controversy began when the results were declared on June 4, resulting in arrests, an expert committee, and calls for a parliamentary debate by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi. President Droupadi Murmu also addressed the issue during a joint session of both Houses.
As India prepares to enforce new criminal laws on July 1, many wonder if the country's police forces are adequately prepared for the changes. The laws, meant to address issues of forced displacement and discrimination against minority groups such as Muslims and Adivasis, raise concerns about how they will be enforced and if they will truly address the underlying issues. This development also highlights the role of moral diplomacy in realpolitik, as seen in India's strained relationships with Israel, Palestine, and Myanmar under the leadership of Janata Dal (United) and PV Narasimha Rao.