A split verdict was delivered by a division bench of Bombay High Court on a group of petitions against the amended IT Rules that include the establishment of a Fact Check Unit (FCU) to identify "fake news" on social media. One of the judges, Justice Gautam Patel, deemed the rules as nothing but censorship while the other judge, Justice Neela Gokhale, upheld the government's arguments. The petitioners, including stand-up comic Kunal Kamra and media associations, argued that the Rules were arbitrary and violated fundamental rights, while the Centre maintained that they were meant to curb the spread of false information related to "government business". Justice Patel struck down the Rules on the grounds of being unconstitutional and violating freedom of speech.
Sure, here's an article revealing more information or background about the split verdict delivered by the Bombay High Court on a group of petitions against the amended IT Rules:
Bombay High Court's Split Verdict on Amended IT Rules: A Deeper Dive
A division bench of the Bombay High Court delivered a split verdict on a group of petitions challenging the amended IT Rules, including the establishment of a Fact Check Unit (FCU) to identify "fake news" on social media. Justice Patel struck down the Rules, deeming them unconstitutional, while Justice Gokhale upheld the government's arguments.
Background
The Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, were introduced by the Indian government in February 2021, amending the existing IT Rules. These amendments included the establishment of the FCU, a three-member body tasked with identifying and flagging "fake news" on social media. The FCU's decisions would be binding on social media platforms, which would be required to remove the flagged content within 24 hours.
Petitioners' Arguments
The petitioners, including stand-up comic Kunal Kamra and media associations, argued that the Rules were arbitrary and violated fundamental rights, such as freedom of speech and expression. They contended that the FCU would be a tool for censorship, allowing the government to suppress dissent and criticism.
Government's Arguments
The Centre maintained that the Rules were meant to curb the spread of false information related to "government business." It argued that the FCU was necessary to protect the public from misinformation and disinformation, especially during times of crisis.
Justice Patel's Verdict
Justice Patel struck down the Rules on the grounds of being unconstitutional and violating freedom of speech. He held that the Rules were vague and overbroad, giving the government unbridled power to censor online content. He also expressed concerns about the lack of transparency and accountability in the FCU's decision-making process.
Justice Gokhale's Verdict
Justice Gokhale upheld the government's arguments, finding that the Rules were a reasonable restriction on freedom of speech. She held that the FCU was necessary to protect the public from misinformation and disinformation, and that the Rules provided sufficient safeguards against arbitrary censorship.
FAQs
The FCU is a three-member body established under the amended IT Rules to identify and flag "fake news" on social media. The FCU's decisions would be binding on social media platforms, which would be required to remove the flagged content within 24 hours.
Justice Patel struck down the Rules on the grounds of being unconstitutional and violating freedom of speech. He held that the Rules were vague and overbroad, giving the government unbridled power to censor online content.
Justice Gokhale upheld the Rules, finding that they were a reasonable restriction on freedom of speech. She held that the FCU was necessary to protect the public from misinformation and disinformation, and that the Rules provided sufficient safeguards against arbitrary censorship.
The split verdict means that the fate of the amended IT Rules now lies with the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court will have to decide whether to uphold Justice Patel's verdict or Justice Gokhale's verdict.
You can find more information on this topic by searching for "Bombay High Court split verdict IT Rules" or by visiting the websites of major news outlets.
Links for Further Information
The Election Commission of India has announced the schedule for the Delhi Assembly Elections 2025, with voting to take place on February 5 and counting of votes on February 8. The recent release of the final electoral roll shows a 1.09 per cent increase in the number of voters since the last draft. CEC Rajiv Kumar addressed concerns over EVMs and the election procedure, asserting the transparency and credibility of the Indian election process. The AAP, BJP and Congress are gearing up for a three-way battle, with the AAP currently in the lead after sweeping 2020 Delhi elections.
With the Delhi Assembly elections just around the corner, AICC Delhi in-charge Qazi Nizamuddin believes that the Congress party will successfully appeal to voters by focusing on key issues affecting citizens. He emphasized that the party only makes promises that have been fulfilled in Congress-ruled states and will prioritize cleaning the Yamuna, improving women's safety, reducing corruption, and addressing unemployment, all of which have been neglected by the current AAP government.
The BJP has refuted Delhi CM Atishi's accusation that her official residence was taken away by the Centre, stating that the allotment was withdrawn for her failure to take possession and ongoing CBI/ED investigation. The AAP leader, however, remains undeterred and vows to work for the people of Delhi even if it means operating from the streets. Delhi's 2025 election poll schedule has also been announced, with voting to take place on February 5 and results on February 8.
During a news conference in Mar-a-Lago, President-elect Donald Trump announced his plan to change the name of the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America. Trump believes that the new name has a "beautiful ring" and is more appropriate, especially given the current state of relations between the US and Mexico. While this isn't the first time renaming the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America has been proposed, Trump's announcement has caused controversy and garnered attention.
The nation bids farewell to former President Jimmy Carter as his funeral procession takes place from the U.S. Navy Memorial to the Capitol in Washington D.C. The event was attended by many political figures and members of the public, paying their respects to the late President. Despite the solemn atmosphere, the streets were lined with people celebrating Carter's life and legacy.
Union Minister of Education Dharmendra Pradhan has released the draft guidelines for the UGC (Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and Academic Staff in Universities and Colleges and Measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher Education) Regulations, 2025. These new regulations aim to bring flexibility, inclusivity, and excellence in faculty recruitment and career progression in Indian higher education institutions. They also align with the goals of the New Education Policy-2020 (NEP-2020) and place emphasis on Indian languages and interdisciplinary backgrounds. Additionally, the guidelines include specialized recruitment pathways for fields such as Yoga, Music, Performing Arts, Visual Arts, Sculpture, and Drama to attract the best talent and preserve India's cultural heritage.
Hickman, a former Parkland High School student, is scheduled to appear in Forsyth Superior Court for slapping a teacher and making threats towards her. The incident was captured on a viral video which showed the teacher remaining calm as she was assaulted and verbally abused. Hickman's case was continued by Judge Aaron Berlin on Monday.
Self-styled godman Asaram, who was convicted in two separate rape cases, has been granted interim bail by the Supreme Court on medical grounds. However, the bail is only until March 31 and he will remain in jail as he has to obtain bail in another rape case. Asaram's request for bail was based on his deteriorating health condition, for which he had previously received treatment in Pune and AIIMS Jodhpur. The Supreme Court also ordered police officers to escort him to the hospital for treatment without imposing any restrictions on where he should go.
In response to concerns raised about discrepancies in voter turnout and vote counting, Chief Election Commissioner Rajiv Kumar clarified the process of EVM commissioning and security measures. He assured the public that EVMs are tamper-proof and backed his statements with court judgments stating that hacking or altering results is impossible. Kumar also explained the mock poll process done in the presence of election agents to further ensure transparency.
The life and papacy of Pope Innocent XI, previously known as Benedetto Odescalchi, was marked by his deep devotion to piety and his relentless efforts to reduce expenses and fight against nepotism in the Curia. He gained admiration from the people of Ferrara as a "father of the poor", and as pope, he faced challenges from Louis XIV of France on the issue of "Gallican Liberties" and ambassadorial immunities. Despite a long period of ill health, Innocent XI left a lasting legacy of selflessness and service, leading to his eventual beatification in 1956.