The second day of the second Test match between India and Australia saw a controversial DRS decision that has raised questions on the use of technology in cricket. Mitchell Marsh was given not out for LBW by the on-field umpire, but replays showed that the ball hit the pad first before hitting the bat. The third umpire deemed that there was not enough conclusive evidence to overturn the on-field umpire's decision. However, slow-motion replays clearly showed that the ball had hit the pad first, causing frustration among Indian fans. On the match front, Australia ended the day at 191 for four, with Travis Head and Marnus Labuschagne leading the charge with their half-centuries.
DRS Controversy Erupts as Marsh's Appeal Raises Questions
Background:
The Decision Review System (DRS) has been introduced in cricket to provide greater accuracy in umpiring decisions. It allows teams to challenge an on-field decision by referring it to the third umpire, who uses video replays and other technology to make a final call.
Current Event:
During the second day of the second Test match between India and Australia in Delhi, Mitchell Marsh was adjudged not out by the on-field umpire despite replays showing that the ball had hit his pad before his bat. The third umpire upheld the original decision due to insufficient evidence.
This decision sparked outrage among Indian fans and commentators, who believed that the replays clearly showed the ball hitting the pad first. It has raised questions about the efficacy of DRS and whether it is being used effectively.
Top 5 FAQs:
1. What is the Decision Review System (DRS)?
DRS allows teams to challenge an on-field decision by referring it to the third umpire for review using video replays and other technology.
2. Why was Mitchell Marsh given not out by the third umpire?
The third umpire deemed that there was not enough conclusive evidence from the replays to overturn the on-field umpire's decision.
3. Have there been other controversial DRS decisions in the past?
Yes, there have been numerous controversial DRS decisions in the past, including the infamous incident in 2013 when England's Joe Root was given not out despite replays clearly showing the ball hitting the stumps.
4. How can DRS be improved?
Suggestions for improving DRS include using enhanced camera angles, increasing the number of cameras used, and improving the training of third umpires.
5. Is DRS a fair and reliable system?
While DRS has been praised for improving the accuracy of umpiring decisions, it is not perfect and there have been instances of incorrect calls. However, the system is constantly being reviewed and updated to ensure it is as fair and reliable as possible.
Conclusion:
The controversial DRS decision during the Delhi Test has reignited discussions about the reliability of technology in cricket. While DRS has the potential to enhance the game, it is essential to ensure that it is used effectively and consistently to avoid further controversies.
India sealed the three-game series in the second match with a dominant display of batting, led by Harleen Deol's century and supported by fifties from Smriti Mandhana, Pratika Rawal, and Jemimah Rodrigues. The West Indies team struggled in response, with Priya Mishra taking three wickets and Deepti Sharma, Titas Sadhu, and Rawal each taking two. With a strong showing, India is looking to cap off the series with another win in the final ODI match.
Indian shooter Manu Bhaker has been in the spotlight for her omission from the list of nominees for the Khel Ratna award. Amid the ongoing controversy, she took to social media to clarify her stance, stating that as an athlete, her priority is to play and perform for her country. She also emphasized that awards are not her ultimate goal, and despite the disappointment, she remains motivated to win more medals for India. The criticism from her coach and father highlights the frustration and disappointment with the sports ministry and selection committee, who overlooked her record-breaking achievements at the Olympics.
The controversy surrounding champion shooter Manu Bhaker's exclusion from the list of nominated athletes for the Khel Ratna award continues as her coach Jaspal Rana criticizes the Sports Ministry, SAI, and NRAI for 'ignoring' her credentials. This comes after Manu herself addressed the issue, stating there might have been a lapse on her part while applying for the award. However, her coach believes that her name should have automatically been considered due to her historic achievements at the Tokyo Olympics where she became the first Indian to win two medals.
As India prepares for the last two Tests of the Border-Gavaskar Trophy against Australia, the sudden retirement of R Ashwin has left a gap in the team's spin attack. In his place, the selectors have called up Mumbai's all-rounder Tanush Kotian, who has 101 wickets under his belt in 31 First-class games. With Washington Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja also in the mix, Kotian's inclusion adds strength to India's spin bowling.
India has selected talented all-rounder Tanush Kotian to join their squad for the fourth and fifth tests of the ongoing Border-Gavaskar Trophy (BGT) 2024-25 series. The series is currently tied 1-1 with India winning in Perth and Australia responding with a victory in Adelaide. The action now moves to Melbourne and Sydney for the final two tests. Kotian, who has had a successful season with Mumbai in the Ranji Trophy, will replace R Ashwin in the squad as he joins the team in Melbourne on Tuesday. This will be his first appearance in the Indian Test squad.
After a tumultuous start to his stint with Real Madrid, French striker Kylian Mbappe has finally found his footing in the team with an impressive run of form. Despite being a World Cup winner and one of the most decisive players in the world, the 26-year-old initially struggled to integrate himself into Carlo Ancelotti's system. However, a crucial missed penalty and the support of his coach have turned things around for Mbappe, who is now settled in the team and playing with confidence.
On Sunday, December 22, Liverpool and Tottenham faced off in a highly anticipated match that ended in a 6-3 victory for Liverpool. With an incredible offensive display, Liverpool's Mohamed Salah led the team to victory with three goals and an assist, solidifying their spot at the top of the Premier League table. The intense back-and-forth game kept fans on the edge of their seats until the final whistle blew.
Fans of Bournemouth were elated as their team secured a 3-0 win against Manchester United at Old Trafford for the second consecutive season. United's defeat pushed them to the 13th spot in the Premier League and highlighted their struggles with anxiety and sloppiness on the field. The Cherries' victory was thanks to goals from Dean Huijsen, Justin Kluivert, and Antoine Semenyo, leaving United fans frustrated with their team's poor performance. With this defeat, United have now conceded nine set-piece goals this season, raising concerns about their defense.
In a heated second ODI match between South Africa and Pakistan, prolific batter Heinrich Klaasen has been fined 15% of his match fee and given a demerit point for violating the ICC Code of Conduct. The incident occurred on December 19, causing a stir in the cricket world. This is not the first time Klaasen has faced disciplinary action, adding to his track record.
Pakistani cricketer Mohammad Amir recently praised Indian cricketer Virat Kohli, calling him the greatest batsman of this generation. Amir believes that Kohli's work ethic and unbeatable record in all three formats of the game make him incomparable to others from this current generation. He also described the special moment of dismissing legendary cricketer Sachin Tendulkar, who he had always admired and considered a brilliant batsman.